The Cane vs Savea Debate
-
Read’s surgery and recovery was a big issue.
At that point, we didn’t have a clear understudy (Probably Squire?), so we were reliant on Read coming back and being as good as he had been.
We had lost Luatua and had a Northern squad fat on 6s and 7s (Cane, Todd, Savea), with one poor selections (Fifita), one who didn’t work out /were unlucky (Squire) plus one who was leaving (Kaino).
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
-
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
-
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@Machpants said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@rotated the original retirement date of post lions should have been kept
Without Read stepping down that would have been a pretty big call to make. Especially that there were no 6s and 8s putting their hands up. He bit the bullet hard to leave out Owen Franks which given the way he fell off the cliff was probably the right call but not going all in with Read would have been a tough call. Honestly other than winning the World cup Hansen was always in a lose lose with almost every decision other than Cody Taylor, Joe Moody and Aaron Smith being open to second guessing.
I don't think anyone is saying exclude him from the squad or even the matchday 22. But if your calculation ends up with Cane on the bench and Read starting you are using the wrong formula. Ditto leaving Laumape at home.
No doubt it would have been a big call, but not unprecedented -captains have been shit canned before. It can also be handled with class. How he made the assessment that Ben Smith was done after a random fixture in Perth, but Read/SBW weren't after two years of pretty average performances is head scratching.
All the justifications to stick with Read and others in the starting XV are the ones that usually come with bad times for the ABs - getting away from merit based selections, picking players on intangibles and holding back young bucks in favour the old guard.
Getting back to the topic I hope with Cane they have learned their lesson and the captaincy call is seen as a 2 year appointment and not one that has to make it through to the RWC at all costs. He will have had a 11 year career at the next RWC and not without injury - unless he is incredibly lucky or canny history suggests someone will be ready to take his spot.
@rotated said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@Machpants said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@rotated the original retirement date of post lions should have been kept
Without Read stepping down that would have been a pretty big call to make. Especially that there were no 6s and 8s putting their hands up. He bit the bullet hard to leave out Owen Franks which given the way he fell off the cliff was probably the right call but not going all in with Read would have been a tough call. Honestly other than winning the World cup Hansen was always in a lose lose with almost every decision other than Cody Taylor, Joe Moody and Aaron Smith being open to second guessing.
I don't think anyone is saying exclude him from the squad or even the matchday 22. But if your calculation ends up with Cane on the bench and Read starting you are using the wrong formula. Ditto leaving Laumape at home.
No doubt it would have been a big call, but not unprecedented -captains have been shit canned before. It can also be handled with class. How he made the assessment that Ben Smith was done after a random fixture in Perth, but Read/SBW weren't after two years of pretty average performances is head scratching.
All the justifications to stick with Read and others in the starting XV are the ones that usually come with bad times for the ABs - getting away from merit based selections, picking players on intangibles and holding back young bucks in favour the old guard.
Getting back to the topic I hope with Cane they have learned their lesson and the captaincy call is seen as a 2 year appointment and not one that has to make it through to the RWC at all costs. He will have had a 11 year career at the next RWC and not without injury - unless he is incredibly lucky or canny history suggests someone will be ready to take his spot.
He was really professional and a great mentor for the young polynesian guys in the team.
Apparently that justified his constant selection.
-
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
-
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Robin Brooke?
-
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Robin Brooke?
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Robin Brooke?
Luke Whitelock
-
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
-
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
-
I'm a Hansen fan in general, but selecting Barrett over Cane was amateur hour. We dominated their lineout in the prior game, but that was a long time ago and a different team, and Jones was not ever going to make that mistake twice.
The mismanagement of Luatua is my biggest gripe though. He needed to be selected consistently, not ditched and left to go offshore. He was the guy who would have overtaken Read in time for the WC. -
I'm a Hansen fan in general, but selecting Barrett over Cane was amateur hour. We dominated their lineout in the prior game, but that was a long time ago and a different team, and Jones was not ever going to make that mistake twice.
The mismanagement of Luatua is my biggest gripe though. He needed to be selected consistently, not ditched and left to go offshore. He was the guy who would have overtaken Read in time for the WC.@reprobate said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
I'm a Hansen fan in general, but selecting Barrett over Cane was amateur hour. We dominated their lineout in the prior game, but that was a long time ago and a different team, and Jones was not ever going to make that mistake twice.
The mismanagement of Luatua is my biggest gripe though. He needed to be selected consistently, not ditched and left to go offshore. He was the guy who would have overtaken Read in time for the WC.I Might be wrong but I don’t reckon it was the line out , Set piece may have been a bit of it,
But I suspect he thought the pack was a bit lightweight Up against England and was adding a bit of bulk , but didn’t want to say that , so used the lineout story ,
Either way , it was a mistake
-
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
-
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
-
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
I wouldn’t be surprised if the AB coaches giving him shit publicly via the media contributed to that mental space he got to. Could have been a completely different story if they had given him less stick and more carrot like they seemed to do with every other player. They also seemed pretty keen on squire even after he pulled himself out for “mental space” issues.
-
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
I wouldn’t be surprised if the AB coaches giving him shit publicly via the media contributed to that mental space he got to. Could have been a completely different story if they had given him less stick and more carrot like they seemed to do with every other player. They also seemed pretty keen on squire even after he pulled himself out for “mental space” issues.
-
@pukunui they seemed pretty keen to pick squire again and again and again regardless of performance...
It’s a weird selection that only really worked against Oz. And, honestly, it was probably the key position that put us in the shit last year.
With Luatua being as good as he was and is, I find that selection blind spot a bit unforgivable.
-
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
I wouldn’t be surprised if the AB coaches giving him shit publicly via the media contributed to that mental space he got to. Could have been a completely different story if they had given him less stick and more carrot like they seemed to do with every other player. They also seemed pretty keen on squire even after he pulled himself out for “mental space” issues.
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
I wouldn’t be surprised if the AB coaches giving him shit publicly via the media contributed to that mental space he got to. Could have been a completely different story if they had given him less stick and more carrot like they seemed to do with every other player. They also seemed pretty keen on squire even after he pulled himself out for “mental space” issues.
Is Tana part of the problem too? Because he wasn’t selecting him to start as well.
-
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
I wouldn’t be surprised if the AB coaches giving him shit publicly via the media contributed to that mental space he got to. Could have been a completely different story if they had given him less stick and more carrot like they seemed to do with every other player. They also seemed pretty keen on squire even after he pulled himself out for “mental space” issues.
Is Tana part of the problem too? Because he wasn’t selecting him to start as well.
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
I wouldn’t be surprised if the AB coaches giving him shit publicly via the media contributed to that mental space he got to. Could have been a completely different story if they had given him less stick and more carrot like they seemed to do with every other player. They also seemed pretty keen on squire even after he pulled himself out for “mental space” issues.
Is Tana part of the problem too? Because he wasn’t selecting him to start as well.
McDonald picked Sotutu over him as well....
-
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
I wouldn’t be surprised if the AB coaches giving him shit publicly via the media contributed to that mental space he got to. Could have been a completely different story if they had given him less stick and more carrot like they seemed to do with every other player. They also seemed pretty keen on squire even after he pulled himself out for “mental space” issues.
Is Tana part of the problem too? Because he wasn’t selecting him to start as well.
McDonald picked Sotutu over him as well....
@canefan said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@DMX said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@ACT-Crusader said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@pukunui said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@shark said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 There was certainly a succession planning issue with Read, but there weren't any clear candidates either after Vito left. In saying that, Vito would have been 32 at last years' RWC. A younger 8 needed to be found. Hansen seemed to fart around trying a heap of guys at 6 but not 8.
If only there had been a young guy who had been killing it in Super rugby over multiple seasons, playing for someone like the Blues, who could have been selected and given some support to iron out any small issues in their game/preparation.
Even better if that guy already had a brother in the team.That might have been handy.
Yes, certainly advantageous to have a brother in the team. And the more, the merrier. Adam Whitelock also could or should have been a stud had he only been given an opportunity alongside Sam, Luke and George, and supported the shit out of.
If only Akira was a Whitelock or a Barrett.
Not another thread hi-jacked...
Hasn't Akira already admitted he wasn't in the correct mental space unless Hansen gets the blame for that as well?
I wouldn’t be surprised if the AB coaches giving him shit publicly via the media contributed to that mental space he got to. Could have been a completely different story if they had given him less stick and more carrot like they seemed to do with every other player. They also seemed pretty keen on squire even after he pulled himself out for “mental space” issues.
Is Tana part of the problem too? Because he wasn’t selecting him to start as well.
McDonald picked Sotutu over him as well....
Because Sotutu is a no8 and Akira is a blindside?
-
It’s a weird selection that only really worked against Oz. And, honestly, it was probably the key position that put us in the shit last year.
With Luatua being as good as he was and is, I find that selection blind spot a bit unforgivable.
@gt12 said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
It’s a weird selection that only really worked against Oz. And, honestly, it was probably the key position that put us in the shit last year.
With Luatua being as good as he was and is, I find that selection blind spot a bit unforgivable.
Kiwis are obsessed with nil by mouth but I find all the screaming really irritating
-
@gt12 said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
It’s a weird selection that only really worked against Oz. And, honestly, it was probably the key position that put us in the shit last year.
With Luatua being as good as he was and is, I find that selection blind spot a bit unforgivable.
Kiwis are obsessed with nil by mouth but I find all the screaming really irritating
@MN5 said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
@gt12 said in The Cane vs Savea Debate:
It’s a weird selection that only really worked against Oz. And, honestly, it was probably the key position that put us in the shit last year.
With Luatua being as good as he was and is, I find that selection blind spot a bit unforgivable.
Kiwis are obsessed with nil by mouth but I find all the screaming really irritating
I think I agree but not sure what you're saying?
