NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II
-
@kiwimurph said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@machpants said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@taniwharugby said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@stargazer which shows how out of touch some laws are with the game.
What, so you're saying it should be ok too pull down a maul right in front of your try line?
100% if he had not done so, it would have been a try. Blatant and cynical foul play.
Prinsep had the ball.
How is that different to someone coming through the maul legally and tackling the player with the ball.
You can't tackle someone in a maul, ball carrier or not
Intentionally collapse a maul or jump on top of it.
Attempt to drag an opponent out of a maul.
Sanction: Penalty.@machpants said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@kiwimurph said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@machpants said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@taniwharugby said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@stargazer which shows how out of touch some laws are with the game.
What, so you're saying it should be ok too pull down a maul right in front of your try line?
100% if he had not done so, it would have been a try. Blatant and cynical foul play.
Prinsep had the ball.
How is that different to someone coming through the maul legally and tackling the player with the ball.
You can't tackle someone in a maul, ball carrier or not
Intentionally collapse a maul or jump on top of it.
Attempt to drag an opponent out of a maul.
Sanction: Penalty.I understand the rule. We are talking about if the rule is right.
-
@chris said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@machpants said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@chris said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
Soft decision
But correct decision
Correct decision just doesn’t add value to the game.
Penalising cheating?
Their forwards aren't quite up to it, so far, but I'm liking Manu Samoa with ball to hand.
-
@taniwharugby said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@stargazer which shows how out of touch some laws are with the game.
What, so you're saying it should be ok too pull down a maul right in front of your try line?
100% if he had not done so, it would have been a try. Blatant and cynical foul play.
@machpants no needing a yc too, I know pro foul and all, but a pt and yc is overkill
-
@machpants no needing a yc too, I know pro foul and all, but a pt and yc is overkill
@taniwharugby so perhaps the ref should have discretion with penalty try and or yellow card? As the rule currently stands, seems to me the tackler knew what he was doing.
-
Hall looks a big improvement!
-
@machpants said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
Nock Vs Hall passing is night and day
Yep different level
-
I personally think Hall is the third best halfback in NZ. I know that he isn’t the future but he could still be playing in 2023. Must be a good tourist as he’d probably just love to be there.
-
Gotta say Hall is playing well so far.
-
@kiwimurph said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
@gt12 he's better than Christie.
He is, and with TJP and Fakatava around, I think Hall would have been a great selection - probably happy to have a few caps and would be a great squaddie.
-
I personally think Hall is the third best halfback in NZ. I know that he isn’t the future but he could still be playing in 2023. Must be a good tourist as he’d probably just love to be there.
@gt12 said in NZ Maori v Manu Samoa II:
I personally think Hall is the third best halfback in NZ. I know that he isn’t the future but he could still be playing in 2023. Must be a good tourist as he’d probably just love to be there.
Yes.. and Nock is the most overrated player on TSF
-
What a difference hall has made
