Skip to content
  • Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

  • Tipping
  • Team Sheets
  • Highlights
  • Results
    • All Blacks

      Search every All Blacks Test. Filter results by year, opposition, location, venue, city and RWC stage

    • Super Rugby

      Search every Super Rugby since match 1996

    • NPC

      Search NPC results. Only first division matches from 1976-2005. All results from the 14 team competition (2006-present) are included

World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Sports Talk
115 Posts 30 Posters 3.9k Views 1 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • RapidoR Rapido

    @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    @rapido said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    so, be born in NZ, learn your rugby in NZ, become a good player on our IP and systems. Make the ABs. Get paid well. Use your new profile to jag a fat overseas contract. Take up said contract, knowing full well you can't play for the ABs any more

    Have a bit of a whinge, play for another team at the next World Cup.

    Have cake. Also eat.

    This doesn't "grow the game" this pretty much just means the same guys play at World Cups but in different jerseys. Maybe Samoa and Tonga (who this is aimed at) make a quarter here or there. Big whoop.

    Great for Charlie Paitau, who now gts to play at the World Cup AND keep his fat UK contract. Bad for the Tongan bloke who will probably qualify them for the tournament, but lose his RWC spot to Charlie.

    Yeah nah.

    This is more targeted at players that might get plucked into say an AB team, get dumped after 1 game and are then in the international wilderness and are playing 2nd div in France.
    If we want a stronger international schedule then we need these guys playing.
    The Piutau's are rare.

    Bollocks it is targeted at that sort of theoretical player.

    A 1 test All Black in the French 2nd Div would be the rare example. You might get a 1 cap Samoan in French 2nd Div swap to Cook Islands.

    Francis Saili (1)? Frank Halai (1)? Seta Tamanivalu (3)?
    All examples of discards not really in the top levels but maybe valuable to other countries.

    Fekitoa (23) has already started his switch through Sevens.

    It's not targeted at them though. It's not targeted at anyone specifically.

    CrucialC Offline
    CrucialC Offline
    Crucial
    wrote on last edited by
    #66

    @rapido said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    @rapido said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

    so, be born in NZ, learn your rugby in NZ, become a good player on our IP and systems. Make the ABs. Get paid well. Use your new profile to jag a fat overseas contract. Take up said contract, knowing full well you can't play for the ABs any more

    Have a bit of a whinge, play for another team at the next World Cup.

    Have cake. Also eat.

    This doesn't "grow the game" this pretty much just means the same guys play at World Cups but in different jerseys. Maybe Samoa and Tonga (who this is aimed at) make a quarter here or there. Big whoop.

    Great for Charlie Paitau, who now gts to play at the World Cup AND keep his fat UK contract. Bad for the Tongan bloke who will probably qualify them for the tournament, but lose his RWC spot to Charlie.

    Yeah nah.

    This is more targeted at players that might get plucked into say an AB team, get dumped after 1 game and are then in the international wilderness and are playing 2nd div in France.
    If we want a stronger international schedule then we need these guys playing.
    The Piutau's are rare.

    Bollocks it is targeted at that sort of theoretical player.

    A 1 test All Black in the French 2nd Div would be the rare example. You might get a 1 cap Samoan in French 2nd Div swap to Cook Islands.

    Francis Saili (1)? Frank Halai (1)? Seta Tamanivalu (3)?
    All examples of discards not really in the top levels but maybe valuable to other countries.

    Fekitoa (23) has already started his switch through Sevens.

    It's not targeted at them though. It's not targeted at anyone specifically.

    I had said that it's more targeted at those types than at the Piutau's that get to benefit all along the chain and I do believe that it was one of the main driving arguments put forward that players of reasonable quality that have lost eligibility through a handful of appearances or Sevens aren't lost to the international game.

    1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • CrucialC Crucial

      @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

      I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

      In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

      rotatedR Offline
      rotatedR Offline
      rotated
      wrote on last edited by rotated
      #67

      @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

      @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

      I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

      In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

      Taking Paul Williams as an example it's not obvious to me why it would be a travesty for him to be ineligible Samoa as a second nation if had already decided to be capped for NZ. Sure there may be a link, but even a parental link is pushing it in many circumstances.

      CrucialC 1 Reply Last reply
      0
      • rotatedR rotated

        @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

        @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

        I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

        In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

        Taking Paul Williams as an example it's not obvious to me why it would be a travesty for him to be ineligible Samoa as a second nation if had already decided to be capped for NZ. Sure there may be a link, but even a parental link is pushing it in many circumstances.

        CrucialC Offline
        CrucialC Offline
        Crucial
        wrote on last edited by
        #68

        @rotated said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

        @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

        @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

        I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

        In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

        Taking Paul Williams as an example it's not obvious to me why it would be a travesty for him to be ineligible Samoa as a second nation if had already decided to be capped for NZ. Sure there may be a link, but even a parental link is pushing it in many circumstances.

        Each circumstance is different quite obviously and although citizenship isn't part of this rule (but is for Olympics), for many places it may well be a travesty that someone can be a citizen (through grandparents) yet not be able to represent that country because they were selected for another some time back.

        I don't understand the opposition to this if it creates better teams and therefore better games to watch.

        Dan54D 1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • CrucialC Crucial

          @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

          so, be born in NZ, learn your rugby in NZ, become a good player on our IP and systems. Make the ABs. Get paid well. Use your new profile to jag a fat overseas contract. Take up said contract, knowing full well you can't play for the ABs any more

          Have a bit of a whinge, play for another team at the next World Cup.

          Have cake. Also eat.

          This doesn't "grow the game" this pretty much just means the same guys play at World Cups but in different jerseys. Maybe Samoa and Tonga (who this is aimed at) make a quarter here or there. Big whoop.

          Great for Charlie Paitau, who now gts to play at the World Cup AND keep his fat UK contract. Bad for the Tongan bloke who will probably qualify them for the tournament, but lose his RWC spot to Charlie.

          Yeah nah.

          This is more targeted at players that might get plucked into say an AB team, get dumped after 1 game and are then in the international wilderness and are playing 2nd div in France.
          If we want a stronger international schedule then we need these guys playing.
          The Piutau's are rare.

          mariner4lifeM Offline
          mariner4lifeM Offline
          mariner4life
          wrote on last edited by
          #69

          @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

          @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

          so, be born in NZ, learn your rugby in NZ, become a good player on our IP and systems. Make the ABs. Get paid well. Use your new profile to jag a fat overseas contract. Take up said contract, knowing full well you can't play for the ABs any more

          Have a bit of a whinge, play for another team at the next World Cup.

          Have cake. Also eat.

          This doesn't "grow the game" this pretty much just means the same guys play at World Cups but in different jerseys. Maybe Samoa and Tonga (who this is aimed at) make a quarter here or there. Big whoop.

          Great for Charlie Paitau, who now gts to play at the World Cup AND keep his fat UK contract. Bad for the Tongan bloke who will probably qualify them for the tournament, but lose his RWC spot to Charlie.

          Yeah nah.

          This is more targeted at players that might get plucked into say an AB team, get dumped after 1 game and are then in the international wilderness and are playing 2nd div in France.
          If we want a stronger international schedule then we need these guys playing.
          The Piutau's are rare.

          I have a bridge to sell you

          NTAN Victor MeldrewV 2 Replies Last reply
          0
          • CrucialC Crucial

            @rotated said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

            @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

            @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

            I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

            In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

            Taking Paul Williams as an example it's not obvious to me why it would be a travesty for him to be ineligible Samoa as a second nation if had already decided to be capped for NZ. Sure there may be a link, but even a parental link is pushing it in many circumstances.

            Each circumstance is different quite obviously and although citizenship isn't part of this rule (but is for Olympics), for many places it may well be a travesty that someone can be a citizen (through grandparents) yet not be able to represent that country because they were selected for another some time back.

            I don't understand the opposition to this if it creates better teams and therefore better games to watch.

            Dan54D Offline
            Dan54D Offline
            Dan54
            wrote on last edited by
            #70

            @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

            @rotated said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

            @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

            @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

            I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

            In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

            Taking Paul Williams as an example it's not obvious to me why it would be a travesty for him to be ineligible Samoa as a second nation if had already decided to be capped for NZ. Sure there may be a link, but even a parental link is pushing it in many circumstances.

            Each circumstance is different quite obviously and although citizenship isn't part of this rule (but is for Olympics), for many places it may well be a travesty that someone can be a citizen (through grandparents) yet not be able to represent that country because they were selected for another some time back.

            I don't understand the opposition to this if it creates better teams and therefore better games to watch.

            I agree Crucial, although there maybe a few cases where it doesn't settle well, in the long run I think it very positive.

            rotatedR 1 Reply Last reply
            1
            • mariner4lifeM mariner4life

              @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

              @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

              so, be born in NZ, learn your rugby in NZ, become a good player on our IP and systems. Make the ABs. Get paid well. Use your new profile to jag a fat overseas contract. Take up said contract, knowing full well you can't play for the ABs any more

              Have a bit of a whinge, play for another team at the next World Cup.

              Have cake. Also eat.

              This doesn't "grow the game" this pretty much just means the same guys play at World Cups but in different jerseys. Maybe Samoa and Tonga (who this is aimed at) make a quarter here or there. Big whoop.

              Great for Charlie Paitau, who now gts to play at the World Cup AND keep his fat UK contract. Bad for the Tongan bloke who will probably qualify them for the tournament, but lose his RWC spot to Charlie.

              Yeah nah.

              This is more targeted at players that might get plucked into say an AB team, get dumped after 1 game and are then in the international wilderness and are playing 2nd div in France.
              If we want a stronger international schedule then we need these guys playing.
              The Piutau's are rare.

              I have a bridge to sell you

              NTAN Offline
              NTAN Offline
              NTA
              wrote on last edited by
              #71

              @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

              @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

              @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

              so, be born in NZ, learn your rugby in NZ, become a good player on our IP and systems. Make the ABs. Get paid well. Use your new profile to jag a fat overseas contract. Take up said contract, knowing full well you can't play for the ABs any more

              Have a bit of a whinge, play for another team at the next World Cup.

              Have cake. Also eat.

              This doesn't "grow the game" this pretty much just means the same guys play at World Cups but in different jerseys. Maybe Samoa and Tonga (who this is aimed at) make a quarter here or there. Big whoop.

              Great for Charlie Paitau, who now gts to play at the World Cup AND keep his fat UK contract. Bad for the Tongan bloke who will probably qualify them for the tournament, but lose his RWC spot to Charlie.

              Yeah nah.

              This is more targeted at players that might get plucked into say an AB team, get dumped after 1 game and are then in the international wilderness and are playing 2nd div in France.
              If we want a stronger international schedule then we need these guys playing.
              The Piutau's are rare.

              I have a bridge to sell you

              4020637d-6968-4cd8-a042-73a4ce78eec0-image.png

              KiwiwombleK 1 Reply Last reply
              9
              • NTAN NTA

                @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                so, be born in NZ, learn your rugby in NZ, become a good player on our IP and systems. Make the ABs. Get paid well. Use your new profile to jag a fat overseas contract. Take up said contract, knowing full well you can't play for the ABs any more

                Have a bit of a whinge, play for another team at the next World Cup.

                Have cake. Also eat.

                This doesn't "grow the game" this pretty much just means the same guys play at World Cups but in different jerseys. Maybe Samoa and Tonga (who this is aimed at) make a quarter here or there. Big whoop.

                Great for Charlie Paitau, who now gts to play at the World Cup AND keep his fat UK contract. Bad for the Tongan bloke who will probably qualify them for the tournament, but lose his RWC spot to Charlie.

                Yeah nah.

                This is more targeted at players that might get plucked into say an AB team, get dumped after 1 game and are then in the international wilderness and are playing 2nd div in France.
                If we want a stronger international schedule then we need these guys playing.
                The Piutau's are rare.

                I have a bridge to sell you

                4020637d-6968-4cd8-a042-73a4ce78eec0-image.png

                KiwiwombleK Offline
                KiwiwombleK Offline
                Kiwiwomble
                wrote on last edited by
                #72

                @nta said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                @mariner4life said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                so, be born in NZ, learn your rugby in NZ, become a good player on our IP and systems. Make the ABs. Get paid well. Use your new profile to jag a fat overseas contract. Take up said contract, knowing full well you can't play for the ABs any more

                Have a bit of a whinge, play for another team at the next World Cup.

                Have cake. Also eat.

                This doesn't "grow the game" this pretty much just means the same guys play at World Cups but in different jerseys. Maybe Samoa and Tonga (who this is aimed at) make a quarter here or there. Big whoop.

                Great for Charlie Paitau, who now gts to play at the World Cup AND keep his fat UK contract. Bad for the Tongan bloke who will probably qualify them for the tournament, but lose his RWC spot to Charlie.

                Yeah nah.

                This is more targeted at players that might get plucked into say an AB team, get dumped after 1 game and are then in the international wilderness and are playing 2nd div in France.
                If we want a stronger international schedule then we need these guys playing.
                The Piutau's are rare.

                I have a bridge to sell you

                4020637d-6968-4cd8-a042-73a4ce78eec0-image.png

                not sure what award category this falls into to but its a winner

                1 Reply Last reply
                1
                • Dan54D Dan54

                  @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  @rotated said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                  In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                  Taking Paul Williams as an example it's not obvious to me why it would be a travesty for him to be ineligible Samoa as a second nation if had already decided to be capped for NZ. Sure there may be a link, but even a parental link is pushing it in many circumstances.

                  Each circumstance is different quite obviously and although citizenship isn't part of this rule (but is for Olympics), for many places it may well be a travesty that someone can be a citizen (through grandparents) yet not be able to represent that country because they were selected for another some time back.

                  I don't understand the opposition to this if it creates better teams and therefore better games to watch.

                  I agree Crucial, although there maybe a few cases where it doesn't settle well, in the long run I think it very positive.

                  rotatedR Offline
                  rotatedR Offline
                  rotated
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #73

                  @dan54 said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  @rotated said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                  I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                  In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                  Taking Paul Williams as an example it's not obvious to me why it would be a travesty for him to be ineligible Samoa as a second nation if had already decided to be capped for NZ. Sure there may be a link, but even a parental link is pushing it in many circumstances.

                  Each circumstance is different quite obviously and although citizenship isn't part of this rule (but is for Olympics), for many places it may well be a travesty that someone can be a citizen (through grandparents) yet not be able to represent that country because they were selected for another some time back.

                  I don't understand the opposition to this if it creates better teams and therefore better games to watch.

                  I agree Crucial, although there maybe a few cases where it doesn't settle well, in the long run I think it very positive.

                  If you eliminate the grandparent rule on the second union only you eliminate 95% of the cases that are taking the piss and still keep most of the benefit.

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  1
                  • TheMojomanT Offline
                    TheMojomanT Offline
                    TheMojoman
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #74

                    Fantastic win for PI rugby. It definitely makes PI teams more competitive from next year and RWC 2023 extremely interesting for the likes of Scotland, Italy and potentially Argentina the way their form has been. At a tournament like RWC they may even cause an upset or two of the Top tier nations.

                    Anyone seen/got a list of potential teams?

                    1 Reply Last reply
                    1
                    • CrucialC Crucial

                      @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                      I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                      In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                      juniorJ Offline
                      juniorJ Offline
                      junior
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #75

                      @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                      @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                      I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                      In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                      I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity. Probably the same for Celtic diaspora in England.

                      NTAN 1 Reply Last reply
                      1
                      • MajorStokesM MajorStokes

                        So howโ€™s it going to work in the real world?

                        All the stars mentioned going to be happy playing for completely amateur unions against their clubs wishes?

                        If it forces the PI top brass to get their shit together can only be good. But pissing off your 7 figure payers to play for the PI unions in their current state simply wonโ€™t work.

                        Dan Leoโ€™s doc was mostly eye opening in the shambolic, corrupt way the countries unions were run. I donโ€™t see how thatโ€™s changed here.

                        juniorJ Offline
                        juniorJ Offline
                        junior
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #76

                        @majorrage said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                        So howโ€™s it going to work in the real world?

                        All the stars mentioned going to be happy playing for completely amateur unions against their clubs wishes?

                        If it forces the PI top brass to get their shit together can only be good. But pissing off your 7 figure payers to play for the PI unions in their current state simply wonโ€™t work.

                        Dan Leoโ€™s doc was mostly eye opening in the shambolic, corrupt way the countries unions were run. I donโ€™t see how thatโ€™s changed here.

                        ThThe PI teams will be stronger at each World Cup, but they will still be complete shit shows in between.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • juniorJ junior

                          @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                          @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                          I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                          In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                          I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity. Probably the same for Celtic diaspora in England.

                          NTAN Offline
                          NTAN Offline
                          NTA
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #77

                          @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                          @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                          @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                          I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                          In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                          I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                          And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                          ๐Ÿ˜‰

                          juniorJ CrucialC 2 Replies Last reply
                          1
                          • G Offline
                            G Offline
                            gibbon rib
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #78

                            I'd be curious to compare a list of unions that voted against this change with a list of teams in the same pool as Tonga or Samoa at the next world cup

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            1
                            • KiwiwombleK Offline
                              KiwiwombleK Offline
                              Kiwiwomble
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #79

                              I, potentially naively, also think we should give these unions credit. they will still prefer some up and comer over some old hat on the verge of retirement. I think 90% of the cases we'll see are either people that have legit only had one or two caps for their first country or they will bring in one or two senior players in key positions

                              I've seen suggestions like Tonga having

                              11 Piutau
                              12 Laumape
                              13 Fekitoa
                              14 NMS
                              15 Folau

                              and Samoa with similar level names, i just cant see it happening, one or two maybe

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              2
                              • NTAN NTA

                                @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                                In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                                I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                                And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                                ๐Ÿ˜‰

                                juniorJ Offline
                                juniorJ Offline
                                junior
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #80

                                @nta said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                                In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                                I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                                And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                                ๐Ÿ˜‰

                                To be fair, as soon as Google became a thing, we had a lot less AB trialists turning out at our club...

                                Dan54D 1 Reply Last reply
                                2
                                • NTAN NTA

                                  @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                  @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                  @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                  I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                                  In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                                  I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                                  And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                                  ๐Ÿ˜‰

                                  CrucialC Offline
                                  CrucialC Offline
                                  Crucial
                                  wrote on last edited by Crucial
                                  #81

                                  @nta said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                  @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                  @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                  @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                  I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                                  In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                                  I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                                  And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                                  ๐Ÿ˜‰

                                  Good to see the club jokes havenโ€™t changed in 20 plus years

                                  NTAN 1 Reply Last reply
                                  3
                                  • BonesB Online
                                    BonesB Online
                                    Bones
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #82

                                    Joey Carberry and Hadleigh Parkes, come on home...

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    1
                                    • CrucialC Crucial

                                      @nta said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                                      In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                                      I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                                      And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                                      ๐Ÿ˜‰

                                      Good to see the club jokes havenโ€™t changed in 20 plus years

                                      NTAN Offline
                                      NTAN Offline
                                      NTA
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #83

                                      @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      @nta said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                      I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                                      In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                                      I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                                      And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                                      ๐Ÿ˜‰

                                      Good to see the club jokes havenโ€™t changed in 20 plus years

                                      I'm not actually joking ๐Ÿ™‚

                                      NTAN 1 Reply Last reply
                                      0
                                      • NTAN NTA

                                        @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @nta said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                                        In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                                        I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                                        And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                                        ๐Ÿ˜‰

                                        Good to see the club jokes havenโ€™t changed in 20 plus years

                                        I'm not actually joking ๐Ÿ™‚

                                        NTAN Offline
                                        NTAN Offline
                                        NTA
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #84

                                        @nta said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @nta said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @crucial said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        @crazy-horse said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        I think stretching it out to a grandparent is too far.

                                        In western terms I generally agree (as in 'my granny was born in Scotland and moved to NZ as a child), but in the PI diaspora I think it is fair enough. The country ties are very strong.

                                        I would also suggest that the ties are strong for the NZ diaspora in Oz, mainly due to proximity.

                                        And the fact every fucking Kiwi at your club will swear on a Bible they were an AB trialist ๐Ÿ™„

                                        ๐Ÿ˜‰

                                        Good to see the club jokes havenโ€™t changed in 20 plus years

                                        I'm not actually joking ๐Ÿ™‚

                                        @junior makes a good point tho:

                                        @junior said in World Rugby Change Eligibigilty Rules:

                                        To be fair, as soon as Google became a thing, we had a lot less AB trialists turning out at our club...

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        0
                                        • StargazerS Offline
                                          StargazerS Offline
                                          Stargazer
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #85

                                          https://twitter.com/nemani_nadolo/status/1463706704105906178

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          2
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Search
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Search