All Blacks 2022
-
@Crucial Not disagreeing with you. I think he is an option although unlikely And this is probably get me thrown under the bus but he does kind of run at the line like cruden.
@broughie said in All Blacks 2022:
@Crucial Not disagreeing with you. I think he is an option although unlikely And this is probably get me thrown under the bus but he does kind of run in the line like cruden.
Another favourite of mine. Had weaknesses but also brought a certain amount of style and difference.
If that Cruden and SBW combo wasn’t ruined by injury it showed brilliance. -
Richie Mo'unga and Mark Telea stand out as thr obvious WTF? Scores
-
-
@broughie said in All Blacks 2022:
@Crucial would like to see him at 1st five. At FB he is rocks or diamonds. Can he kick for territory and control the game that way. Always thought he would have been a brilliant halfback. Do we need one of those :-).
Halfback would reduce his opportunity to do some of the things he did well but I agree that it would be interesting.
I’m not saying he should be AB 10 just that he has some of the qualities that the others lack.
As a bench option instead of BB (with Jordan at 15) he could be the ideal spark.@Crucial said in All Blacks 2022:
@broughie said in All Blacks 2022:
@Crucial would like to see him at 1st five. At FB he is rocks or diamonds. Can he kick for territory and control the game that way. Always thought he would have been a brilliant halfback. Do we need one of those :-).
Halfback would reduce his opportunity to do some of the things he did well but I agree that it would be interesting.
I’m not saying he should be AB 10 just that he has some of the qualities that the others lack.
As a bench option instead of BB (with Jordan at 15) he could be the ideal spark.I’ve been a big beaudie fan but if everyone is fit and available, you could now ask the question without being a hater , is he needed in the 23 ?
Heading into similar territory as cane .
-
@Crucial said in All Blacks 2022:
@broughie said in All Blacks 2022:
@Crucial would like to see him at 1st five. At FB he is rocks or diamonds. Can he kick for territory and control the game that way. Always thought he would have been a brilliant halfback. Do we need one of those :-).
Halfback would reduce his opportunity to do some of the things he did well but I agree that it would be interesting.
I’m not saying he should be AB 10 just that he has some of the qualities that the others lack.
As a bench option instead of BB (with Jordan at 15) he could be the ideal spark.I’ve been a big beaudie fan but if everyone is fit and available, you could now ask the question without being a hater , is he needed in the 23 ?
Heading into similar territory as cane .
@kiwiinmelb I think you need BB for a couple of things, among the most important, we don't have another backline leader. I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15, as I really think he goes missing under high ball etc too much. Wonderful attacker, but on this years form pretty erratic, was pretty average in Irish series where he looked almost to have no interest at all at times.
-
@Crucial said in All Blacks 2022:
@broughie said in All Blacks 2022:
@Crucial would like to see him at 1st five. At FB he is rocks or diamonds. Can he kick for territory and control the game that way. Always thought he would have been a brilliant halfback. Do we need one of those :-).
Halfback would reduce his opportunity to do some of the things he did well but I agree that it would be interesting.
I’m not saying he should be AB 10 just that he has some of the qualities that the others lack.
As a bench option instead of BB (with Jordan at 15) he could be the ideal spark.I’ve been a big beaudie fan but if everyone is fit and available, you could now ask the question without being a hater , is he needed in the 23 ?
Heading into similar territory as cane .
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2022:
@Crucial said in All Blacks 2022:
@broughie said in All Blacks 2022:
@Crucial would like to see him at 1st five. At FB he is rocks or diamonds. Can he kick for territory and control the game that way. Always thought he would have been a brilliant halfback. Do we need one of those :-).
Halfback would reduce his opportunity to do some of the things he did well but I agree that it would be interesting.
I’m not saying he should be AB 10 just that he has some of the qualities that the others lack.
As a bench option instead of BB (with Jordan at 15) he could be the ideal spark.I’ve been a big beaudie fan but if everyone is fit and available, you could now ask the question without being a hater , is he needed in the 23 ?
Heading into similar territory as cane .
He isn't the player he once was. But I don't think our gameplan is making he or RM look as good as they could be either
-
@kiwiinmelb I think you need BB for a couple of things, among the most important, we don't have another backline leader. I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15, as I really think he goes missing under high ball etc too much. Wonderful attacker, but on this years form pretty erratic, was pretty average in Irish series where he looked almost to have no interest at all at times.
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2022:
I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15,
There's a presumption by some on here that WJ will slot in at 15 and dominate. I'm yet to be convniced that his game will translate to Tests. I suspect it's irrelevant anywya; he hasn't really played there at the top level yet, and doesn't ahve the experience. Frankly, like it or lump it, BB is locked in. It's Codie Taylor all over agin; Foster's going to try to play him into form for the pointy end of the tournament.
-
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2022:
I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15,
There's a presumption by some on here that WJ will slot in at 15 and dominate. I'm yet to be convniced that his game will translate to Tests. I suspect it's irrelevant anywya; he hasn't really played there at the top level yet, and doesn't ahve the experience. Frankly, like it or lump it, BB is locked in. It's Codie Taylor all over agin; Foster's going to try to play him into form for the pointy end of the tournament.
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2022:
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2022:
I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15,
There's a presumption by some on here that WJ will slot in at 15 and dominate. I'm yet to be convniced that his game will translate to Tests. I suspect it's irrelevant anywya; he hasn't really played there at the top level yet, and doesn't ahve the experience. Frankly, like it or lump it, BB is locked in. It's Codie Taylor all over agin; Foster's going to try to play him into form for the pointy end of the tournament.
And his experience is important for RM, who needs the help frankly.
-
@kiwiinmelb I think you need BB for a couple of things, among the most important, we don't have another backline leader. I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15, as I really think he goes missing under high ball etc too much. Wonderful attacker, but on this years form pretty erratic, was pretty average in Irish series where he looked almost to have no interest at all at times.
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2022:
@kiwiinmelb I think you need BB for a couple of things, among the most important, we don't have another backline leader. I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15, as I really think he goes missing under high ball etc too much. Wonderful attacker, but on this years form pretty erratic, was pretty average in Irish series where he looked almost to have no interest at all at times.
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2022:
@kiwiinmelb I think you need BB for a couple of things, among the most important, we don't have another backline leader. I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15, as I really think he goes missing under high ball etc too much. Wonderful attacker, but on this years form pretty erratic, was pretty average in Irish series where he looked almost to have no interest at all at times.
I have those concerns as well and we do know that sometimes Super Rugby standouts don't work at test level. I am hoping that Jordan's lacklustre showings mid year had other reasons behind them.
You are right about the leadership aspect. We really miss having that Conrad Smith type thinker with authority in the middle of the backs. RM needs to step up more and yes, we do then need someone at the back. If DMac ended up there somehow then he is actually good in that area. Very vocal and good at directing his wings. -
I wonder whether Will Jordan's performance for the ABs this year has been affected by him getting Covid at the beginning of the July Series. As we've seen with a player like Ngane Punivai, long-covid can affect players badly. Maybe Jordan had some lingering issues because of that Covid infection (like fatigue)? Or did his inner ear issues start already during the Rugby Championship? Obviously, we'll never get the answers to these questions.
-
Jordan was coming back into form at the end of the RC, was really excited about what he was going to do on the EOYT, gutted he missed it. I prefer him on the wing with a license to roam.
-
@kiwiinmelb I think you need BB for a couple of things, among the most important, we don't have another backline leader. I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15, as I really think he goes missing under high ball etc too much. Wonderful attacker, but on this years form pretty erratic, was pretty average in Irish series where he looked almost to have no interest at all at times.
@Dan54 said in All Blacks 2022:
@kiwiinmelb I think you need BB for a couple of things, among the most important, we don't have another backline leader. I perhaps not as convinced about Jordan at 15, as I really think he goes missing under high ball etc too much. Wonderful attacker, but on this years form pretty erratic, was pretty average in Irish series where he looked almost to have no interest at all at times.
You could well be right , I’m not convinced he should go , but I would at least have liked to see Jordan there to see what it looks like .
I wonder if that was about to happen on the eyot, in the game when Jordie played 15 .
-
To Ryan's credit, he spoke to Barnes about Sowakula's NPC form prior to naming the AB XV squad.
-
@Bones said in All Blacks 2022:
No one is bigger than the jersey. BB will almost certainly make the RWC23 team, then he should go abroad and enjoy his semi-retirement
-
@Bones said in All Blacks 2022:
No one is bigger than the jersey. BB will almost certainly make the RWC23 team, then he should go abroad and enjoy his semi-retirement
@canefan yeah I can kinda see how something like what Aus do might work, and having it set at say 80 caps and only if you didn't take a sabbatical - but then I think what we have now has generally worked in the past anyway.
Only player I can really think of right now that's worth it would be Smith, but then that's purely due to the gap behind him, which would be bridged in a year or two anyway.
-
Fuck off beauden. Go now champ.
