Foster, Robertson etc
-
In all seriousness though I'd be really happy if Schmidt got the role, he's my preferred candidate.
@No-Quarter said in Foster, Robertson etc:
In all seriousness though I'd be really happy if Schmidt got the role, he's my preferred candidate.
Yes he did a great job with Ireland and left there a winner. He also a very charismatic fellow.
PS I was sure you were trolling. But now I'm not sure. In any event, I would have no issue if they ditched Foster for him just for 2023.
-
@Chester-Draws said in Foster, Robertson etc:
Edit: I have gone from disliking Foster, through despising him, to outright hating what he has done. I may no longer be entirely objective. I no longer care.
I go along with Mariner, you obviously need help, to hate someone you don't know and then to boast publicly about it screams of either needing help, or a 5yo kid has your log in details.
@Dan54 said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Chester-Draws said in Foster, Robertson etc:
Edit: I have gone from disliking Foster, through despising him, to outright hating what he has done. I may no longer be entirely objective. I no longer care.
I go along with Mariner, you obviously need help, to hate someone you don't know and then to boast publicly about it screams of either needing help, or a 5yo kid has your log in details.
I didn't actually say I hate Foster. I said I hate what he has done (to the ABs).
He seems an amiable man, as a person.
Edit, probably should have also made it clear dislike and despise what he has done.
-
In all seriousness though I'd be really happy if Schmidt got the role, he's my preferred candidate.
@No-Quarter said in Foster, Robertson etc:
In all seriousness though I'd be really happy if Schmidt got the role, he's my preferred candidate.
Schmidt was also my preferred candidate in 2019, but 4 years have passed since then and after the debacle of 2022 if NZR have any integrity they should reward Razor's loyalty.
He was mucked around last year, he was given assurances of the job, he would've gone overseas already if those assurances weren't genuine.
He's clearly been told something - as he's stuck around despite what happened last year, so if NZR value integrity they will appoint him.
-
@No-Quarter said in Foster, Robertson etc:
In all seriousness though I'd be really happy if Schmidt got the role, he's my preferred candidate.
Schmidt was also my preferred candidate in 2019, but 4 years have passed since then and after the debacle of 2022 if NZR have any integrity they should reward Razor's loyalty.
He was mucked around last year, he was given assurances of the job, he would've gone overseas already if those assurances weren't genuine.
He's clearly been told something - as he's stuck around despite what happened last year, so if NZR value integrity they will appoint him.
@Asterik6 said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@No-Quarter said in Foster, Robertson etc:
In all seriousness though I'd be really happy if Schmidt got the role, he's my preferred candidate.
Schmidt was also my preferred candidate in 2019, but 4 years have passed since then and after the debacle of 2022 if NZR have any integrity they should reward Razor's loyalty.
He was mucked around last year, he was given assurances of the job, he would've gone overseas already if those assurances weren't genuine.
He's clearly been told something - as he's stuck around despite what happened last year, so if NZR value integrity they will appoint him.
If Schmidt wants to stay on with him, even better
-
I think NZR have already given Razor "assurances" that the job will be his post-2023, hence his media comments, however they are going through the current process in order to appear professional and to give NZ public the impression that they're doing their 'due diligence' this time and covering 'all-bases' this time round after how shambolic the process was in 2019.
-
I think NZR have already given Razor "assurances" that the job will be his post-2023, hence his media comments, however they are going through the current process in order to appear professional and to give NZ public the impression that they're doing their 'due diligence' this time and covering 'all-bases' this time round after how shambolic the process was in 2019.
@Asterik6 said in Foster, Robertson etc:
I think NZR have already given Razor "assurances" that the job will be his post-2023, hence his media comments, however they are going through the current process in order to appear professional and to give NZ public the perception that they're doing their 'due diligence' this time and covering 'all-bases' this time round after how shambolic the process was in 2019.
The Problem for Razor with that is NZR seem to have been pretty free with implying,hinting,Whichever you prefer,IF the rumours are true about previous situations.
I would not be holding my breath until the contact is signed sealed and delivered. -
I think NZR have already given Razor "assurances" that the job will be his post-2023, hence his media comments, however they are going through the current process in order to appear professional and to give NZ public the impression that they're doing their 'due diligence' this time and covering 'all-bases' this time round after how shambolic the process was in 2019.
@Asterik6 said in Foster, Robertson etc:
I think NZR have already given Razor "assurances" that the job will be his post-2023, hence his media comments, however they are going through the current process in order to appear professional and to give NZ public the impression that they're doing their 'due diligence' this time and covering 'all-bases' this time round after how shambolic the process was in 2019.
people complained thats what happened last time, so shouldnt be happy if its happening again
-
A Razor, Schmidt combo would cover all bases, wouldn't it?
-
Wait, so now both Schmidt and Razor have already been given the job?
This Love Island Finale is going to be epic
-
Schmidt obviously has some good qualities as a coach but he is also a coach with two 'failures' at RWCs.
-
Schmidt obviously has some good qualities as a coach but he is also a coach with two 'failures' at RWCs.
-
@Crucial said in Foster, Robertson etc:
Schmidt obviously has some good qualities as a coach but he is also a coach with two 'failures' at RWCs.
Schmidt: coaches side to number 1 in world.
Fern: FAILURE
@nzzp said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Crucial said in Foster, Robertson etc:
Schmidt obviously has some good qualities as a coach but he is also a coach with two 'failures' at RWCs.
Schmidt: coaches side to number 1 in world.
Fern: FAILURE
NZ of all nations should understand how hard it is to win RWCs. After all it took us 24 years between cup wins #1 and #2
-
@Kiwiwomble said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Foster, Robertson etc:
I can't believe people have the energy to keep this up every day. Pace yourself. You'll need that energy once
SchmitHammett is announced as coach.FIFY
If that happens I'll make the rest of this thread look like a warm up.
@Nepia said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Kiwiwomble said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Foster, Robertson etc:
I can't believe people have the energy to keep this up every day. Pace yourself. You'll need that energy once
SchmitHammett is announced as coach.FIFY
If that happens I'll make the rest of this thread look like a warm up.
-
@Nepia said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Kiwiwomble said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Foster, Robertson etc:
I can't believe people have the energy to keep this up every day. Pace yourself. You'll need that energy once
SchmitHammett is announced as coach.FIFY
If that happens I'll make the rest of this thread look like a warm up.
@Victor-Meldrew said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Nepia said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Kiwiwomble said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Foster, Robertson etc:
I can't believe people have the energy to keep this up every day. Pace yourself. You'll need that energy once
SchmitHammett is announced as coach.FIFY
If that happens I'll make the rest of this thread look like a warm up.
-
@nzzp said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Crucial said in Foster, Robertson etc:
Schmidt obviously has some good qualities as a coach but he is also a coach with two 'failures' at RWCs.
Schmidt: coaches side to number 1 in world.
Fern: FAILURE
NZ of all nations should understand how hard it is to win RWCs. After all it took us 24 years between cup wins #1 and #2
@canefan said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@nzzp said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Crucial said in Foster, Robertson etc:
Schmidt obviously has some good qualities as a coach but he is also a coach with two 'failures' at RWCs.
Schmidt: coaches side to number 1 in world.
Fern: FAILURE
NZ of all nations should understand how hard it is to win RWCs. After all it took us 24 years between cup wins #1 and #2
Can I save this for when we dip out in the quarters?
Schmidt took two Ireland teams that were on hot streaks to World Cups and never made it into the top four.
He did a great job getting the team up the rankings, winning 6Ns etc but couldn’t get performances when it counted.
His successor has improved his team.
I’m not quite sure why some here think he is what we need. -
@canefan said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@nzzp said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Crucial said in Foster, Robertson etc:
Schmidt obviously has some good qualities as a coach but he is also a coach with two 'failures' at RWCs.
Schmidt: coaches side to number 1 in world.
Fern: FAILURE
NZ of all nations should understand how hard it is to win RWCs. After all it took us 24 years between cup wins #1 and #2
Can I save this for when we dip out in the quarters?
Schmidt took two Ireland teams that were on hot streaks to World Cups and never made it into the top four.
He did a great job getting the team up the rankings, winning 6Ns etc but couldn’t get performances when it counted.
His successor has improved his team.
I’m not quite sure why some here think he is what we need.@Crucial said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@canefan said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@nzzp said in Foster, Robertson etc:
@Crucial said in Foster, Robertson etc:
Schmidt obviously has some good qualities as a coach but he is also a coach with two 'failures' at RWCs.
Schmidt: coaches side to number 1 in world.
Fern: FAILURE
NZ of all nations should understand how hard it is to win RWCs. After all it took us 24 years between cup wins #1 and #2
Can I save this for when we dip out in the quarters?
Schmidt took two Ireland teams that were on hot streaks to World Cups and never made it into the top four.
He did a great job getting the team up the rankings, winning 6Ns etc but couldn’t get performances when it counted.
His successor has improved his team.
I’m not quite sure why some here think he is what we need.If we get bounced in the QF I will be disappointed but not surprised
-
The problem with Schmit's Irish teams was that their highly attritional game plan made it hard for them to back up 2 huge games. They'd effectively blown their load against France in 2015 and the preceeding 3 years had taken their toll in 2019. They had nothing left in the tank. Not conducive at all to tournament rugby. He wouldn't have to do that with the ABs and there are certainly elements from those Irish teams that would be nice to see in the ABs. Some forward muscle for starters!
But I don't believe for a second he'll be head coach. How can you sell that to the NZ rugby public? Unless they discover a decomposed corpse in his car or he badly injures himself breakdancing, it will be Razor.
-
The problem with Schmit's Irish teams was that their highly attritional game plan made it hard for them to back up 2 huge games. They'd effectively blown their load against France in 2015 and the preceeding 3 years had taken their toll in 2019. They had nothing left in the tank. Not conducive at all to tournament rugby. He wouldn't have to do that with the ABs and there are certainly elements from those Irish teams that would be nice to see in the ABs. Some forward muscle for starters!
But I don't believe for a second he'll be head coach. How can you sell that to the NZ rugby public? Unless they discover a decomposed corpse in his car or he badly injures himself breakdancing, it will be Razor.
@Rancid-Schnitzel said in Foster, Robertson etc:
The problem with Schmit's Irish teams was that their highly attritional game plan made it hard for them to back up 2 huge games. They'd effectively blown their load against France in 2015 and the preceeding 3 years had taken their toll in 2019. They had nothing left in the tank. Not conducive at all to tournament rugby. He wouldn't have to do that with the ABs and there are certainly elements from those Irish teams that would be nice to see in the ABs. Some forward muscle for starters!
But I don't believe for a second he'll be head coach. How can you sell that to the NZ rugby public? Unless they discover a decomposed corpse in his car or he badly injures himself breakdancing, it will be Razor.
I'd be happy with either but with a serious review after 1 and 2 years and not just on the coaching, but also on what in NZ rugby is impacting AB success. Thought the latter should have happened last year.
