2023 School Rugby
-
@Bovidae said in 2023 School Rugby:
So Scots have only been given a written warning. They better find some props before the PNBHS game.
That's bullshit. They gamed the system and they've gotten away with it.
@Nepia said in 2023 School Rugby:
@Bovidae said in 2023 School Rugby:
So Scots have only been given a written warning. They better find some props before the PNBHS game.
That's bullshit. They gamed the system and they've gotten away with it.
It appears so. Poor from the NZR panel to overturn the decision. Everyone will be hoping that PNBHS smash them in the scrums, and that the ref isn't fooled.
-
@Nepia said in 2023 School Rugby:
@Bovidae said in 2023 School Rugby:
So Scots have only been given a written warning. They better find some props before the PNBHS game.
That's bullshit. They gamed the system and they've gotten away with it.
It appears so. Poor from the NZR panel to overturn the decision. Everyone will be hoping that PNBHS smash them in the scrums, and that the ref isn't fooled.
@Bovidae I never thought I'd support Palmy Boys, but Scots simply don't deserve to be in the Hurricanes Final, let alone the Top 4. I feel for those Feilding boys, who've probably trained all week, just in case, and now their season is suddenly over and the cheating school goes through.
-
@Nepia said in 2023 School Rugby:
@Bovidae said in 2023 School Rugby:
So Scots have only been given a written warning. They better find some props before the PNBHS game.
That's bullshit. They gamed the system and they've gotten away with it.
It appears so. Poor from the NZR panel to overturn the decision. Everyone will be hoping that PNBHS smash them in the scrums, and that the ref isn't fooled.
@Bovidae said in 2023 School Rugby:
@Nepia said in 2023 School Rugby:
@Bovidae said in 2023 School Rugby:
So Scots have only been given a written warning. They better find some props before the PNBHS game.
That's bullshit. They gamed the system and they've gotten away with it.
It appears so. Poor from the NZR panel to overturn the decision. Everyone will be hoping that PNBHS smash them in the scrums, and that the ref isn't fooled.
Palmy had the edge over Napier in the scrums I saw last week (got there just after half time) and the Napier scrum is usually pretty good so the Palmy pack must have something going for them judging by that performance.
-
You have to feel for FAHS now.
It is with great pleasure we announce that Palmerston North Boys' High are the Hurricanes 1st XV Champs. We were advised this evening that their opposition tomorrow was unable to field the required number of trained front-row players so have regrettably had to withdraw their challenge.
-
You have to feel for FAHS now.
It is with great pleasure we announce that Palmerston North Boys' High are the Hurricanes 1st XV Champs. We were advised this evening that their opposition tomorrow was unable to field the required number of trained front-row players so have regrettably had to withdraw their challenge.
@Bovidae What the heck? Why couldn't FAHS just take their place in the Hurricanes Final? They have trained all week, awaiting the outcome of theirs and Scot's appeal! Scots really f*cked them over. They probably knew all the time they couldn't field enough frontrowers. They didn't need to appeal. If they hadn't, the decision on FAHS appeal would have stood and FAHS would have played the Final against Palmy.
-
@Bovidae What the heck? Why couldn't FAHS just take their place in the Hurricanes Final? They have trained all week, awaiting the outcome of theirs and Scot's appeal! Scots really f*cked them over. They probably knew all the time they couldn't field enough frontrowers. They didn't need to appeal. If they hadn't, the decision on FAHS appeal would have stood and FAHS would have played the Final against Palmy.
@Stargazer Yeah, it's messy. Neither PNBHS or FAHS would need to travel for the Top 4 so they could have played on Sunday/Monday.
-
You have to feel for FAHS now.
It is with great pleasure we announce that Palmerston North Boys' High are the Hurricanes 1st XV Champs. We were advised this evening that their opposition tomorrow was unable to field the required number of trained front-row players so have regrettably had to withdraw their challenge.
@Bovidae said in 2023 School Rugby:
You have to feel for FAHS now.
It is with great pleasure we announce that Palmerston North Boys' High are the Hurricanes 1st XV Champs. We were advised this evening that their opposition tomorrow was unable to field the required number of trained front-row players so have regrettably had to withdraw their challenge.
WTF. You couldn't write a script this stupid. Who runs this shit show?
-
Just left watching Westlake boys beat sacred heart 32-31. They led by 15 with 15 to go after being down 14-8 at HT but let sacred heart back in to it.
Back to back blues champs for Westlake!
-
@JK I did say earlier that I wouldn't be surprised to see Westlake win this game. They are my pick to win it all.
I see that Hamilton BHS made a late charge but lost to TBC. Home field advantage was always going to be big in this game.
@Bovidae said in 2023 School Rugby:
@JK I did say earlier that I wouldn't be surprised to see Westlake win this game. They are my pick to win it all.
I see that Hamilton BHS made a late charge but lost to TBC. Home field advantage was always going to be big in this game.
Damn so much drama in schools rugby this year, interesting bunch of teams to go through to the Top 4, some weird home ground advantages, TJ taking a shot at the A1 on Sky broadcast, and a Wellington school blatantly cheating in the Canes competition and being given a pass for it.
-
@Stargazer 33-26.
-
@JK said in 2023 School Rugby:
I don’t think any of these 4 have won it before so we will have a new champ.
Yes. Looking at the records, Southland BHS lost in the 1987 final and Palmerston North BHS lost in 1996 and 1997.
2012 is the last time a South Island school even made the final (Otago BHS).
-
is that the official game footage? seems to be spending all its time on their bench as if they were looking for something
that is criminal, could the final not have been pushed a week and FAHS play it as they deserve too? looks like Scots were just trying to punish FAHS
-
is that the official game footage? seems to be spending all its time on their bench as if they were looking for something
that is criminal, could the final not have been pushed a week and FAHS play it as they deserve too? looks like Scots were just trying to punish FAHS
@Kiwiwomble I don't think it's the official game footage, but I'd say the person behind the camera knew something fishy was about to happen. Why else would they focus on the team management and bench?
There was no time to play the final a week later! The Top 4 starts this Friday!
