All Blacks 2024
-
Apologies if this question has been asked and answered - how many players have been used by razor this year?
-
@ARHS how many new caps? 7 that I can think of?
Bell, Tosi, Sititi, Ratima, Love, Lakai & Plummer?
Which in itself isnt bad, but certainly seems many under-used, particularly the last 3.
-
Don't know if this has been posted anywhere.
if so, please delete
@MiketheSnow This has been discussed on Exodus for a few days. Good for him, I don't think he was going to get any serious game time in Black while Robertson remains All Blacks coach.
-
@ARHS how many new caps? 7 that I can think of?
Bell, Tosi, Sititi, Ratima, Love, Lakai & Plummer?
Which in itself isnt bad, but certainly seems many under-used, particularly the last 3.
-
@ARHS how many new caps? 7 that I can think of?
Bell, Tosi, Sititi, Ratima, Love, Lakai & Plummer?
Which in itself isnt bad, but certainly seems many under-used, particularly the last 3.
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2024:
@ARHS how many new caps? 7 that I can think of?
Bell, Tosi, Sititi, Ratima, Love, Lakai & Plummer?
Which in itself isnt bad, but certainly seems many under-used, particularly the last 3.
Hotham Darry Proctor 10 I think
-
@taniwharugby a few more than that. Proctor, Darry etc
But yes Love has a total of 22 minutes and Plummer has a total of 3 minutes.
@KiwiMurph I knew I'd be forgetting some.
So 10, again, is pretty good on one hand, but you would say over half have been massively under used, especially when you look at the aging or out of form players that have sat in front of them.
-
Most of the minutes for the majority of these other players were against Fiji and Japan. Bell also got a token 1 min in the Ireland game, so what was the point of that? Perofeta wasn't even used in that test.
Beauden must have a good contract that stipulates selection every week.
-
i feel like the NZ rugby media is trying to gaslight me
Paul Cully did a World XV article today, and put the "consistently excellent" Ardie Savea in it. At openside. The fuck?
He also added Wallace Sititi, which in itself is not a terrible call, but at #8?Apparently Rob Valetini doesn't exist aye Paul?
-
Whilst Newell is a good scrummager - his scrummaging at test level doesn't seem to generate penalties the way it does at Super.
Given Newell is poor around the field I don't think the trade off is worth it at test level.
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2024:
Whilst Newell is a good scrummager - his scrummaging at test level doesn't seem to generate penalties the way it does at Super.
Given Newell is poor around the field I don't think the trade off is worth it at test level.
Newell is a good cleaner and tackler. Like De Groot and Lomax he offers little to nothing as a carrier.
-
i feel like the NZ rugby media is trying to gaslight me
Paul Cully did a World XV article today, and put the "consistently excellent" Ardie Savea in it. At openside. The fuck?
He also added Wallace Sititi, which in itself is not a terrible call, but at #8?Apparently Rob Valetini doesn't exist aye Paul?
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2024:
i feel like the NZ rugby media is trying to gaslight me
Paul Cully did a World XV article today, and put the "consistently excellent" Ardie Savea in it. At openside. The fuck?
He also added Wallace Sititi, which in itself is not a terrible call, but at #8?Apparently Rob Valetini doesn't exist aye Paul?
i had a discussion with someone this week who insisted "everyone" knows BB has been consistently excellent this year.....i feel like im going insane
-
Ardie Savea hasn't been any where near as bad as what people have made out.
However after watching the last two Irish games I think you'd have to be having a laugh to pick him at 7 over JVDF.
@brodean said in All Blacks 2024:
Ardie Savea hasn't been any where near as bad as what people have made out.
hard disagree
And the season's MotM polling seems to suggest i am far from alone.
Savea right now has a total of 2 points. For a guy who is the VC, started and played 80 in every test bar Fiji and Japan, and plays in a high profile position, that's about as underwhelming as it gets.
The only loose forward with less points is Ethan Blackadder. -
@brodean said in All Blacks 2024:
Ardie Savea hasn't been any where near as bad as what people have made out.
hard disagree
And the season's MotM polling seems to suggest i am far from alone.
Savea right now has a total of 2 points. For a guy who is the VC, started and played 80 in every test bar Fiji and Japan, and plays in a high profile position, that's about as underwhelming as it gets.
The only loose forward with less points is Ethan Blackadder.@mariner4life dont forget a player that was the road block to the super rugby players of the year getting a run for the AB's
-
i feel like the NZ rugby media is trying to gaslight me
Paul Cully did a World XV article today, and put the "consistently excellent" Ardie Savea in it. At openside. The fuck?
He also added Wallace Sititi, which in itself is not a terrible call, but at #8?Apparently Rob Valetini doesn't exist aye Paul?
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2024:
i feel like the NZ rugby media is trying to gaslight me
Paul Cully did a World XV article today, and put the "consistently excellent" Ardie Savea in it. At openside. The fuck?
He also added Wallace Sititi, which in itself is not a terrible call, but at #8?Apparently Rob Valetini doesn't exist aye Paul?
Was thinking that it's getting near time to do the TSF TOTY and thinking there'd not be many All Blacks getting nominated.
-
@brodean said in All Blacks 2024:
Ardie Savea hasn't been any where near as bad as what people have made out.
hard disagree
And the season's MotM polling seems to suggest i am far from alone.
Savea right now has a total of 2 points. For a guy who is the VC, started and played 80 in every test bar Fiji and Japan, and plays in a high profile position, that's about as underwhelming as it gets.
The only loose forward with less points is Ethan Blackadder.@mariner4life yep, although, most pundits that arent Kiwis seem to think he has played well this year
-
@mariner4life yep, although, most pundits that arent Kiwis seem to think he has played well this year
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2024:
@mariner4life yep, although, most pundits that arent Kiwis seem to think he has played well this year
im not convinced overseas commenters aren't only watching the highlights
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2024:
@mariner4life yep, although, most pundits that arent Kiwis seem to think he has played well this year
im not convinced overseas commenters aren't only watching the highlights
@Kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2024:
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2024:
@mariner4life yep, although, most pundits that arent Kiwis seem to think he has played well this year
im not convinced overseas commenters aren't only watching the highlights
there haven't exactly been a lot of those this year. certainly not like in previous years
-
@Kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2024:
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2024:
@mariner4life yep, although, most pundits that arent Kiwis seem to think he has played well this year
im not convinced overseas commenters aren't only watching the highlights
there haven't exactly been a lot of those this year. certainly not like in previous years
@mariner4life true, i guess also just easy to fill some column space saying last years world player of the year is doing well again
-
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2024:
@mariner4life yep, although, most pundits that arent Kiwis seem to think he has played well this year
im not convinced overseas commenters aren't only watching the highlights
@Kiwiwomble I don't doubt that for some, but not all.
He certainly hasn't been at his YouTube reel best this year.
