The dreaded box kick
-
-
@canefan said in The dreaded box kick:
The Boks won't be that bad again. If we give the ball away in attacking areas we will lose in Saturday
But they kicked away a lot of possession over the first 60-65 minutes. It wasn't until the last 10 minutes when they started to dominate the possession.
Sure they might not make as many errors, but they will have to change their tactics even when they do have the ball to create enough scoring opportunities.
Plus their defence over the first 3 matches of the RC has been shown up to be quite porous.
-
I reckon start by removing the caterpillar ruck, allowing the 9 to roll it back and set for the box kick.
Agree with @MiketheSnow hands on, you are free game, like it used to be as opposed to the roll it back, move it into ideal position, head up looking if the kick is still on, wait, kick
-
@taniwharugby said in The dreaded box kick:
I reckon start by removing the caterpillar ruck, allowing the 9 to roll it back and set for the box kick.
Agree with @MiketheSnow hands on, you are free game, like it used to be as opposed to the roll it back, move it into ideal position, head up looking if the kick is still on, wait, kick
I like the concept, but think you will find the ball is just buried in rucks longer, or we will end up with endless pick and goes until the halfback has got room. Trouble is whatever law is changed, the coaches then brainstorm how to get around it.
-
Harry Jones, SA podcaster, had some interesting thoughts on Devlin's DSPN shown yesterday on why box kicks are the only option as the risk of turnover inside your half is too great (and other stuff I can't remember).
Follows on from Skinstad's thoughts about playing with territory to give you more chance of defending.
-
@Dan54 I get that.
As I said, start with the caterpillar, and then maybe make it 2 hands on ball, fair game, menaing they can dig it out still...but def kill the caterpillar
-
@booboo said in The dreaded box kick:
Harry Jones, SA podcaster, had some interesting thoughts on Devlin's DSPN shown yesterday on why box kicks are the only option as the risk of turnover inside your half is too great (and other stuff I can't remember).
Follows on from Skinstad's thoughts about playing with territory to give you more chance of defending.
This would make sense if we actually kicked long regularly, instead of often putting up box kicks from our own 22 that land (uncontested) on halfway!
I am firmly in the camp of hating box kicks. I would much rather see 12 phases of play, even if not much ground is made.
I also hate the cross kick, and was saying to a mate before Bok 1 how at least that seems to have disappeared from our game - so naturally we score off one immediately last week
-
@voodoo said in The dreaded box kick:
@booboo said in The dreaded box kick:
Harry Jones, SA podcaster, had some interesting thoughts on Devlin's DSPN shown yesterday on why box kicks are the only option as the risk of turnover inside your half is too great (and other stuff I can't remember).
Follows on from Skinstad's thoughts about playing with territory to give you more chance of defending.
This would make sense if we actually kicked long regularly, instead of often putting up box kicks from our own 22 that land (uncontested) on halfway!
I am firmly in the camp of hating box kicks. I would much rather see 12 phases of play, even if not much ground is made.
I also hate the cross kick, and was saying to a mate before Bok 1 how at least that seems to have disappeared from our game - so naturally we score off one immediately last week
The problem with 12 phases of play, as someone mentioned above or on another thread, is that if your ball is slow with modern defences it is too easy to get turned over, pushed back, or penalised.
I am starting to think we need to consider pushing the defensive line back from where it is now.
-
@Goffman said in The dreaded box kick:
@voodoo said in The dreaded box kick:
@booboo said in The dreaded box kick:
Harry Jones, SA podcaster, had some interesting thoughts on Devlin's DSPN shown yesterday on why box kicks are the only option as the risk of turnover inside your half is too great (and other stuff I can't remember).
Follows on from Skinstad's thoughts about playing with territory to give you more chance of defending.
This would make sense if we actually kicked long regularly, instead of often putting up box kicks from our own 22 that land (uncontested) on halfway!
I am firmly in the camp of hating box kicks. I would much rather see 12 phases of play, even if not much ground is made.
I also hate the cross kick, and was saying to a mate before Bok 1 how at least that seems to have disappeared from our game - so naturally we score off one immediately last week
The problem with 12 phases of play, as someone mentioned above or on another thread, is that if your ball is slow with modern defences it is too easy to get turned over, pushed back, or penalised.
I am starting to think we need to consider pushing the defensive line back from where it is now.
Yeah, I understand the risk, and hence the reason fror the kick - just saying I don't like to see it - from a pure enjoyment perspective I'd rather see 12 phases of pick-and-go, blokes running full steam into each other, tackle and contest, ruck and counter-ruck - than a contested 50/50 high ball that almost always results in some sloppy fumble or tap back - it's rugby union I came to see, not fricken AFL!!!
-
@voodoo said in The dreaded box kick:
@Goffman said in The dreaded box kick:
@voodoo said in The dreaded box kick:
@booboo said in The dreaded box kick:
Harry Jones, SA podcaster, had some interesting thoughts on Devlin's DSPN shown yesterday on why box kicks are the only option as the risk of turnover inside your half is too great (and other stuff I can't remember).
Follows on from Skinstad's thoughts about playing with territory to give you more chance of defending.
This would make sense if we actually kicked long regularly, instead of often putting up box kicks from our own 22 that land (uncontested) on halfway!
I am firmly in the camp of hating box kicks. I would much rather see 12 phases of play, even if not much ground is made.
I also hate the cross kick, and was saying to a mate before Bok 1 how at least that seems to have disappeared from our game - so naturally we score off one immediately last week
The problem with 12 phases of play, as someone mentioned above or on another thread, is that if your ball is slow with modern defences it is too easy to get turned over, pushed back, or penalised.
I am starting to think we need to consider pushing the defensive line back from where it is now.
Yeah, I understand the risk, and hence the reason fror the kick - just saying I don't like to see it - from a pure enjoyment perspective I'd rather see 12 phases of pick-and-go, blokes running full steam into each other, tackle and contest, ruck and counter-ruck - than a contested 50/50 high ball that almost always results in some sloppy fumble or tap back - it's rugby union I came to see, not fricken AFL!!!
Yeah I figured you'd understand the risk, I was just thinking aloud.
-
@MiketheSnow said in The dreaded box kick:
It can be stopped overnight
Soon as the 9 touches the ball he gets splattered
Absolutely. Limit teams to only being able to add one player to their caterpillar ruck. AND if the halfback uses their hands to get the ball from the ruck, it's out. It's BS that refs allow halfbacks to pick the ball up and then place it on the ground again when the majority of the time it's their own teammates who are restricting access to the ball.
-
@taniwharugby said in The dreaded box kick:
@Dan54 I get that.
As I said, start with the caterpillar, and then maybe make it 2 hands on ball, fair game, menaing they can dig it out still...but def kill the caterpillar
Would love to see it killed off mate, no argument. And all the protection halfbacks get!
-
I'll send you all out t-shirts
-
-
@mariner4life said in The dreaded box kick:
I'll send you all out t-shirts
I'm an Extra Small
, thanks mate -
@voodoo said in The dreaded box kick:
@mariner4life said in The dreaded box kick:
I'll send you all out t-shirts
I'm an Extra Small
, thanks mateand your shirt size?
