All Blacks - New Coach Selection
-
That article hints that Joseph chased away some talented assistants, one of whom I'd really like to have back in NZ (Kenny Lynn).
My biggest issue with Joseph is that he never really did much with the Japanese team, so in terms of international experience - especially of which we care right now, such as identifying and bringing through young talent - Rennie has actually worked with a higher tier team and he was doing fantastic things with that young Wallaby group. He was properly screwed and good fucking job for taking on that role (sorry, I had to sneak in one shot).
@gt12 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
That article hints that Joseph chased away some talented assistants, one of whom I'd really like to have back in NZ (Kenny Lynn).
My biggest issue with Joseph is that he never really did much with the Japanese team, so in terms of international experience - especially of which we care right now, such as identifying and bringing through young talent - Rennie has actually worked with a higher tier team and he was doing fantastic things with that young Wallaby group. He was properly screwed and good fucking job for taking on that role (sorry, I had to sneak in one shot).
I’m not sure it is fair to make an argument that Joseph didn’t do much (made a RWC QF), and to say Rennie did fantastic things.
As for the assistants. He didn’t get on with Tom Donnelly, but he sucked. He got on well with Kenny Lynn, but the offer to go to international rugby was too good. He has been mentioned to me as a possible Joseph Head Coach replacement. Dillon was let to go to bring in Kidwell, early days but looks a master stroke. Unsure on Flutey, but he was no great loss.
-
@frugby said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
I think the idea that it takes New Zealand Rugby the best part of two months to pick between the two blokes they were almost certainly considering when they made the call to sack Robertson probably hasn't received enough heat.
They should have identified their candidates, and carried out interviews and a full process within two weeks. It isn't like they didn't know who was available when they made the call. I could understand if there was a delay due to a contracting issue, but the leaks are that they are carrying out a process of some description with Rennie this week. Makes you wonder what they were actually doing in the three weeks after Robertson was sacked.
And imagine how many would be in forums/papers talking about rushed process etc. There is no way only 2 blokes should of been considered, and they seem to be looking at both coaches actually doing job, and talking to those involved with them. I say good take your time and get it right. The general rugby population in NZ would expect the job to be done properly.
@Dan54 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@frugby said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
I think the idea that it takes New Zealand Rugby the best part of two months to pick between the two blokes they were almost certainly considering when they made the call to sack Robertson probably hasn't received enough heat.
They should have identified their candidates, and carried out interviews and a full process within two weeks. It isn't like they didn't know who was available when they made the call. I could understand if there was a delay due to a contracting issue, but the leaks are that they are carrying out a process of some description with Rennie this week. Makes you wonder what they were actually doing in the three weeks after Robertson was sacked.
There is no way only 2 blokes should of been considered, and they seem to be looking at both coaches actually doing job, and talking to those involved with them.
Who else is worthy of consideration? When you factor in, they in their own mind already have Joseph as the number one local option, that leaves him and Rennie.
And I have no issue with them doing due-dilligence, but I can’t see how or why that takes two months.
-
@Dan54 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
the Black jersey is everything.
this is such outdated bullshit that absolutely will not resonate at all.
These guys know rugby as nothing else but their job. They're aren't rugby nuffies talking shit on the internet, they are young guys with a certain set of skills that allow them to make a good living. Did they once play for fun? yes. But they were in the pro pipeline since they were kids.
To them the Black jersey lets them play test rugby and be well remunerated while living in NZ, and most probably very little else.
"pashun!" doesn't win professional rugby games, plans, skills, and execution does.
@mariner4life said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@Dan54 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
the Black jersey is everything.
this is such outdated bullshit that absolutely will not resonate at all.
These guys know rugby as nothing else but their job. They're aren't rugby nuffies talking shit on the internet, they are young guys with a certain set of skills that allow them to make a good living. Did they once play for fun? yes. But they were in the pro pipeline since they were kids.
To them the Black jersey lets them play test rugby and be well remunerated while living in NZ, and most probably very little else.
"pashun!" doesn't win professional rugby games, plans, skills, and execution does.
100%.
At provincial, franchise and national level it always amazes me broken down old blokes think these young lads should have loyalty to specific jerseys. That they should fight for it.
Nah fuck that. In no other sector would you to someone, Jhonny you always dreamt of working for XX company. You need to grind to get there. If they aren't hiring you, you need to pixk yourself up and try again. Don't be a quitter and chase money elsewhere.
Rugby is no different
-
@Dan54 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@Frank said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@gt12 Liam Napier has been saying who he prefers for the past few weeks.
I think his two points are strong.
- Rennie has the superior overall record.
- Rennie is a superior man manager to Joseph
Actually at test rugby JJ's record is stronger as Rennie coached Wallabies to their worst ever record. Though I don't take lot of notice of that, and no idea of either's man management.
But Napier like any of us can select any points that works to push the case of who he prefers.Rennie doesn't have the worst Aus record of the pro era (that's Jones 22%) Rennie's record is roughly same as Schmidt around 40%.
You're also got to remember Dave essentially built the entire spine of Schmidt's Wallabies - all their most valuable players Bell, Valetini, Frost, Ikitau, McReight, Wilson, McDermott, T.Wright, etc.. were all developed by Rennie (he blooded them all very early, Bell was just 20 years old on debut) after Wallabies lost almost all their senior players post-2019.
Rennie had the biggest rebuild job in Wallabies history, combined with Covid destroying Australian rugby financially (to the point where the game was on the brink of having to revert back to amateur status) I can't think of any Wallabies coach who was subject to worse circumstances than Rennie.
@restofit said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
Rennie doesn't have the worst Aus record of the pro era (that's Jones 22%) Rennie's record is roughly same as Schmidt around 40%.
You're also got to remember Dave essentially built the entire spine of Schmidt's Wallabies - all their most valuable players Bell, Valetini, Frost, Ikitau, McReight, Wilson, McDermott, T.Wright, etc.. were all developed by Rennie (he blooded them all very early, Bell was just 20 years old on debut) after Wallabies lost almost all their senior players post-2019.
Rennie had the biggest rebuild job in Wallabies history, combined with Covid destroying Australian rugby financially (to the point where the game was on the brink of having to revert back to amateur status) I can't think of any Wallabies coach who was subject to worse circumstances than Rennie.
I'd just about disregard his time with the wobs, Aus rugby was a complete mess at the time.
Ask Raelene.
Another coach might have done a better job than him, but not much better. -
I think the idea that it takes New Zealand Rugby the best part of two months to pick between the two blokes they were almost certainly considering when they made the call to sack Robertson probably hasn't received enough heat.
They should have identified their candidates, and carried out interviews and a full process within two weeks. It isn't like they didn't know who was available when they made the call. I could understand if there was a delay due to a contracting issue, but the leaks are that they are carrying out a process of some description with Rennie this week. Makes you wonder what they were actually doing in the three weeks after Robertson was sacked.
I like that they are taking their time.
Plenty of time available; make sure you consider all possible options, not like the last 3 BS HC selection processes.
Even if someone like Rennie doesn't get the job; all other future candidates will see that he got a good opportunity to put his case.
That has to be good. -
@Dan54 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
the Black jersey is everything.
this is such outdated bullshit that absolutely will not resonate at all.
These guys know rugby as nothing else but their job. They're aren't rugby nuffies talking shit on the internet, they are young guys with a certain set of skills that allow them to make a good living. Did they once play for fun? yes. But they were in the pro pipeline since they were kids.
To them the Black jersey lets them play test rugby and be well remunerated while living in NZ, and most probably very little else.
"pashun!" doesn't win professional rugby games, plans, skills, and execution does.
@mariner4life said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
this is such outdated bullshit that absolutely will not resonate at all.
still resonates a little bit . . . maybe
but the remuneration aspect is f'n huge now. -
A bit of Goss
@mikedogz said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
A bit of Goss
The scariest part of that is that Joseph is considering to keep David Brent around.
-
Interesting if true I dont mind Rennies assistants.Barnes,Strawbridge and Mike Blair
Joseph maybe will keep Hanson,Ryan and Ellison -
@Chris do you think Ryan stays in a setup under Rennie as Barnes isn't a scrum coach and they'll need one.
@restofit said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@Chris do you think Ryan stays in a setup under Rennie as Barnes isn't a scrum coach and they'll need one.
Why not keep Feek? Isn't he still in that role?
Edit: Maybe not, seems to be with the Blues, but could be easy to add back I guess.
-
That's not a terrible team: Rennie, Barnes, Strawbridge, and Blair.
That would be all with overseas experience at the international level (Australia, Canada, All Blacks & England, Scotland).@gt12 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
That's not a terrible team: Rennie, Barnes, Strawbridge, and Blair.
That would be all with overseas experience at the international level (Australia, Canada, All Blacks & England, Scotland).Blair's the only surprise of that lot (but still makes sense) - the rest are fairly predictable.
I guess it would be Blair coaching the backs, Barnes the forwards, and Strawbridge as skills? Both Blair and Strawbridge have focused primarily on attack coaching, from what I remember.
-
@gt12 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
That's not a terrible team: Rennie, Barnes, Strawbridge, and Blair.
That would be all with overseas experience at the international level (Australia, Canada, All Blacks & England, Scotland).Blair's the only surprise of that lot (but still makes sense) - the rest are fairly predictable.
I guess it would be Blair coaching the backs, Barnes the forwards, and Strawbridge as skills? Both Blair and Strawbridge have focused primarily on attack coaching, from what I remember.
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@gt12 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
That's not a terrible team: Rennie, Barnes, Strawbridge, and Blair.
That would be all with overseas experience at the international level (Australia, Canada, All Blacks & England, Scotland).Blair's the only surprise of that lot (but still makes sense) - the rest are fairly predictable.
I guess it would be Blair coaching the backs, Barnes the forwards, and Strawbridge as skills? Both Blair and Strawbridge have focused primarily on attack coaching, from what I remember.
Strawbridge skills and player development I assume. Then, they can fill in the specialist positions with what we currently are using (Feek, Evans etc.).
I'd love to hear who Joseph has in mind as that clip only said he would work with the current team, not that they were his preferred team.
-
@Frank said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
I'm not as worried about lead in time
Razor had more than a year between his last Super game coached and his first AB game as coach and it was certainly not apparent.
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
I'm not as worried about lead in time
Razor had more than a year between his last Super game coached and his first AB game as coach and it was certainly not apparent.
That's a point that bears repeating.
You can say that again.....
Anyway, I don't think timings are key - much more important to get the new coach and his team right. That can be done in a way that doesn't stiff any SR side.
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@Frank said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
I'm not as worried about lead in time
Razor had more than a year between his last Super game coached and his first AB game as coach and it was certainly not apparent.
@KiwiMurph said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
I'm not as worried about lead in time
Razor had more than a year between his last Super game coached and his first AB game as coach and it was certainly not apparent.
That's a point that bears repeating.
You can say that again.....
Anyway, I don't think timings are key - much more important to get the new coach and his team right. That can be done in a way that doesn't stiff any SR side.
Your new Avatar is disconcerting.
I dont like change.
-
Not a good look for Jamie Joseph if he really is 'miffed' by scrutiny.
I'm taking this article with a long pinch of salt though.
https://www.sarugbymag.co.za/joseph-miffed-by-nz-rugby-observation/
-
Not a good look for Jamie Joseph if he really is 'miffed' by scrutiny.
I'm taking this article with a long pinch of salt though.
https://www.sarugbymag.co.za/joseph-miffed-by-nz-rugby-observation/
@sparky said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
Not a good look for Jamie Joseph if he really is 'miffed' by scrutiny.
Possibly checking the head coach is doing the coaching he says he is. Interesting though, it's definitely due diligence but you'd need permission to acces thos trainings. What happens if they get turned down?
-
Not a good look for Jamie Joseph if he really is 'miffed' by scrutiny.
I'm taking this article with a long pinch of salt though.
https://www.sarugbymag.co.za/joseph-miffed-by-nz-rugby-observation/
@sparky said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
Not a good look for Jamie Joseph if he really is 'miffed' by scrutiny.
I'm taking this article with a long pinch of salt though.
https://www.sarugbymag.co.za/joseph-miffed-by-nz-rugby-observation/
Very much part of the discussion of 'reporters' putting across what they want the public to see?
-
@gt12 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
That article hints that Joseph chased away some talented assistants, one of whom I'd really like to have back in NZ (Kenny Lynn).
My biggest issue with Joseph is that he never really did much with the Japanese team, so in terms of international experience - especially of which we care right now, such as identifying and bringing through young talent - Rennie has actually worked with a higher tier team and he was doing fantastic things with that young Wallaby group. He was properly screwed and good fucking job for taking on that role (sorry, I had to sneak in one shot).
I’m not sure it is fair to make an argument that Joseph didn’t do much (made a RWC QF), and to say Rennie did fantastic things.
As for the assistants. He didn’t get on with Tom Donnelly, but he sucked. He got on well with Kenny Lynn, but the offer to go to international rugby was too good. He has been mentioned to me as a possible Joseph Head Coach replacement. Dillon was let to go to bring in Kidwell, early days but looks a master stroke. Unsure on Flutey, but he was no great loss.
@frugby said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@gt12 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
That article hints that Joseph chased away some talented assistants, one of whom I'd really like to have back in NZ (Kenny Lynn).
My biggest issue with Joseph is that he never really did much with the Japanese team, so in terms of international experience - especially of which we care right now, such as identifying and bringing through young talent - Rennie has actually worked with a higher tier team and he was doing fantastic things with that young Wallaby group. He was properly screwed and good fucking job for taking on that role (sorry, I had to sneak in one shot).
I’m not sure it is fair to make an argument that Joseph didn’t do much (made a RWC QF), and to say Rennie did fantastic things.
As for the assistants. He didn’t get on with Tom Donnelly, but he sucked. He got on well with Kenny Lynn, but the offer to go to international rugby was too good. He has been mentioned to me as a possible Joseph Head Coach replacement. Dillon was let to go to bring in Kidwell, early days but looks a master stroke. Unsure on Flutey, but he was no great loss.
@frugby said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
@gt12 said in All Blacks - New Coach Selection:
That article hints that Joseph chased away some talented assistants, one of whom I'd really like to have back in NZ (Kenny Lynn).
My biggest issue with Joseph is that he never really did much with the Japanese team, so in terms of international experience - especially of which we care right now, such as identifying and bringing through young talent - Rennie has actually worked with a higher tier team and he was doing fantastic things with that young Wallaby group. He was properly screwed and good fucking job for taking on that role (sorry, I had to sneak in one shot).
I’m not sure it is fair to make an argument that Joseph didn’t do much (made a RWC QF), and to say Rennie did fantastic things.
As for the assistants. He didn’t get on with Tom Donnelly, but he sucked. He got on well with Kenny Lynn, but the offer to go to international rugby was too good. He has been mentioned to me as a possible Joseph Head Coach replacement. Dillon was let to go to bring in Kidwell, early days but looks a master stroke. Unsure on Flutey, but he was no great loss.
Yes Tom Donnelly has done awful things for the wallabies forwards under Schmidt…
