ABs vs Kangaroos?
-
@raznomore said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
@antipodean I think the best spectacle is to go more into the league variant.
Then what's the point if you remove the very thing that makes the two games different; a contest for possession? That's a spectacle like Joseph Merrick
@antipodean which is why it'd never truly work.
As it is, the hybrid version wants to go back 30 years to pre-lifting days.
Reckon their best bet, would be to get 20 Union players to play League, just for the festival side of things, whereas finding a competent forward pack of league players in Australia purely for the safety side of things would be impossible
-
@antipodean which is why it'd never truly work.
As it is, the hybrid version wants to go back 30 years to pre-lifting days.
Reckon their best bet, would be to get 20 Union players to play League, just for the festival side of things, whereas finding a competent forward pack of league players in Australia purely for the safety side of things would be impossible
-
@taniwharugby yip thats essentially it in a nut shell. Forget about which is the better game. We know that already, make it about which is the better athlete.
@raznomore said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
@taniwharugby yip thats essentially it in a nut shell. Forget about which is the better game. We know that already, make it about which is the better athlete.
A decathlon?
-
@raznomore said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
@taniwharugby yip thats essentially it in a nut shell. Forget about which is the better game. We know that already, make it about which is the better athlete.
A decathlon?
-
@antipodean eat some ice cream do some bombs!
@taniwharugby said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
@antipodean eat some ice cream do some bombs!
-
@taniwharugby said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
@antipodean eat some ice cream do some bombs!
-
I reckon a game of 7s that had a mix of ABs/Kiwis vs Wallabies/Kangaroos would be fun to watch.
-
More pertinent, a 2003 clash between a now fully professional Sale and St Helens was also played (one half of each code). Jason Robinson was playing for Sale.
Sale won the 1st half of RU 41-0 and St Helens scored 39 pts in the 2nd half of RL. Final score 41-39.
@bovidae said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
More pertinent, a 2003 clash between a now fully professional Sale and St Helens was also played (one half of each code). Jason Robinson was playing for Sale.
Sale won the 1st half of RU 41-0 and St Helens scored 39 pts in the 2nd half of RL. Final score 41-39.
That was fun to watch even though each team only scored when their code was played!
-
The window was apparently two weeks to a month after the RWC. Yeah OK. Win, lose or draw there's no fucking way the abs would want to play a game like that right after the RWC.
I don't mind if club teams or even a select group of players do something like this, but not the abs. No way.
@rancid-schnitzel said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
The window was apparently two weeks to a month after the RWC. Yeah OK. Win, lose or draw there's no fucking way the abs would want to play a game like that right after the RWC.
I don't mind if club teams or even a select group of players do something like this, but not the abs. No way.
Win , they will be celebrating and wont want to see another football for sometime
Lose , they will be sulking and wont want to see another football for sometime
-
Read some comments online from mainly (Aussie) league fans, who didn't want this because:
league is a far more intelligent game than union and they didn't want to be dragged down to union's level,
league is a far superior game to union and league players are far superior athletes than union players,
the Kangaroos would crush the ABs (the only thing they seemed to like about it).
They also said the ABs didn't want it because they were scared.Hahaha
hahahahahahaha 
hahahahahahaha hahahahahaha Hahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahaha Hahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahaha
Ha hahahahahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahahaha
Hahahahaha hahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha hahaha
Ha hahahahahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahahaha Hahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahaha
Ha hahahahahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahahaha
Hahahahaha hahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha hahaha
Hahahahaha hahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha hahaha
Ha hahahahahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahahaha
Hahahahaha hahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha hahahaHahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahaha
Ha hahahahahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahahaha
Hahahahaha hahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha hahaha
Hahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahaha
Ha hahahahahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahahaha
Hahahahaha hahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha hahaha'Hahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahahaha hahahahahaha
Ha hahahahahahahahahahahaha hahahahahahahahahaha
Hahahahaha hahahahahaha hahahahahahahahaha hahahaetc etc etc
-
The Mayweather v MacGregor comparison is an interesting one... and makes me think the "hybrid" idea is farcical.
The Herald today reports Kangaroos surprised by news of a ABs v Roos clash, call it a "pipe dream," yet they welcome it.
Mel Maninga is quoted as saying, "Anything that's going to help promote both games ... playing against the All Blacks, they've got a worldwide brand. From a Kangaroos point of view that would certainly help that."
(Emphasis mine.)
He's right. ABs have a worldwide brand. Kangaroos are nowehere close. (Sorry Okkers; sorry League fans, but it's true.) ABs are the world's best rugby team. As Ric Flair sez, "If You Wanna Be the Man, You've Got To Beat The Man."
If the Floyd v Conor fight had attempted to be a hybrid "sports entertainment" event between boxing & mma it would have been an absurd mess. So kudos to the latter, who had to STEP UP into the ring to face the master at his level of expertise, and although nobody gave him a chance he acquitted himself very well.
If Roos want to prove a point, pump petrol into their brand and make a ton of cash, they should learn & practice real rugby and take the ABs on at XVs. That's something people would pay to see. Roos need to take step UP; ABs should not debase themselves stepping down to play a junk hybrid joke. To be the man, you've got to beat the man.
-
It'll only ever happen on a video game. The codes are vastly different and besides who is going to insure all the players? I wouldn't want to go down in history as the AB who's career got cut short because of an injury in a game like that
@canefan said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
It'll only ever happen on a video game. The codes are vastly different and besides who is going to insure all the players? I wouldn't want to go down in history as the AB who's career got cut short because of an injury in a game like that
So no-one should play Barbarians either, because there's a risk of injury and the game doesn't matter? The (alleged) huge payout vs the Kangaroos would more than cover the insurance.
It is a fahken stupid idea. It's not the risk of injury, but the fact that all the players in the ABs would have to suspend their rugby training to learn another game. Only to then have to unlearn it. Why would the coaches want their team to do that? Just after a World Cup would do the least amount of damage in that regard, but it's still not a good idea to train for the wrong game.
And after the RWC the ABs will be badly needing a rest and in no mood to take on a new challenge. They would have no focus, most having just passed the major peak of their careers.
-
@canefan said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
It'll only ever happen on a video game. The codes are vastly different and besides who is going to insure all the players? I wouldn't want to go down in history as the AB who's career got cut short because of an injury in a game like that
So no-one should play Barbarians either, because there's a risk of injury and the game doesn't matter? The (alleged) huge payout vs the Kangaroos would more than cover the insurance.
It is a fahken stupid idea. It's not the risk of injury, but the fact that all the players in the ABs would have to suspend their rugby training to learn another game. Only to then have to unlearn it. Why would the coaches want their team to do that? Just after a World Cup would do the least amount of damage in that regard, but it's still not a good idea to train for the wrong game.
And after the RWC the ABs will be badly needing a rest and in no mood to take on a new challenge. They would have no focus, most having just passed the major peak of their careers.
@chester-draws learning a new code to be able to keep up with seasoned test players would be difficult in a short time. Just look how long it took BBBT and Sonny
-
cant see this posted elsewhere, but...
-
cant see this posted elsewhere, but...
@taniwharugby said in AB Depth Chart 2020:
cant see this posted elsewhere, but...
i just saw that
yawn
-
cant see this posted elsewhere, but...
@taniwharugby said in ABs vs Kangaroos?:
cant see this posted elsewhere, but...
I moved it to the thread where it was last mentioned
Once every three years seems about right for this rumour. League writers must be getting bored again
-
cant see this posted elsewhere, but...
@taniwharugby said in AB Depth Chart 2020:
cant see this posted elsewhere, but...
If I was a player insurer I would be saying “no cover” to that.
Willingly putting yourself on the field under untried rules with others who have an instinct to shoulder smash you is a recipe for injury.
