Skip to content
  • Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

  • Tipping
  • Team Sheets
  • Highlights
  • Results
    • All Blacks

      Search every All Blacks Test. Filter results by year, opposition, location, venue, city and RWC stage

    • Super Rugby

      Search every Super Rugby since match 1996

    • NPC

      Search NPC results. Only first division matches from 1976-2005. All results from the 14 team competition (2006-present) are included

Chiefs 2020

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Sports Talk
chiefs
828 Posts 64 Posters 57.9k Views 4 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • antipodeanA antipodean

    @Bovidae "Should" - the main benefit will be the experience and knowledge he brings to his understudies.

    BovidaeB Offline
    BovidaeB Offline
    Bovidae
    wrote on last edited by
    #202

    @antipodean "Should" as in Cruden needs to stay injury free to reach that milestone. The article touches on the benefits he will bring off the field, including mentoring the younger backs.

    1 Reply Last reply
    2
    • YeetyaahY Offline
      YeetyaahY Offline
      Yeetyaah
      wrote on last edited by
      #203

      https://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/rugby/rugby-news/welsh-rugby-region-closing-deal-17200879

      MMac seems to be heading to Wales. Can we celebrate this as a small victory?

      CrucialC 1 Reply Last reply
      1
      • YeetyaahY Yeetyaah

        https://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/rugby/rugby-news/welsh-rugby-region-closing-deal-17200879

        MMac seems to be heading to Wales. Can we celebrate this as a small victory?

        CrucialC Offline
        CrucialC Offline
        Crucial
        wrote on last edited by
        #204

        @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

        https://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/rugby/rugby-news/welsh-rugby-region-closing-deal-17200879

        MMac seems to be heading to Wales. Can we celebrate this as a small victory?

        The land that loves our mediocre first-fives....

        Nah, good on him, will probably do well up there. Actually has solid skills and a lot of experience. Will suit no risk competition rugby.

        YeetyaahY 1 Reply Last reply
        1
        • CrucialC Crucial

          @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

          https://www.walesonline.co.uk/sport/rugby/rugby-news/welsh-rugby-region-closing-deal-17200879

          MMac seems to be heading to Wales. Can we celebrate this as a small victory?

          The land that loves our mediocre first-fives....

          Nah, good on him, will probably do well up there. Actually has solid skills and a lot of experience. Will suit no risk competition rugby.

          YeetyaahY Offline
          YeetyaahY Offline
          Yeetyaah
          wrote on last edited by
          #205

          @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

          CrucialC 1 Reply Last reply
          2
          • gt12G Offline
            gt12G Offline
            gt12
            wrote on last edited by
            #206

            Good move, raises the level of both teams.

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • YeetyaahY Yeetyaah

              @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

              CrucialC Offline
              CrucialC Offline
              Crucial
              wrote on last edited by
              #207

              @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

              @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

              I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

              I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
              Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

              mariner4lifeM 1 Reply Last reply
              4
              • CrucialC Crucial

                @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                mariner4lifeM Offline
                mariner4lifeM Offline
                mariner4life
                wrote on last edited by
                #208

                @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                gt12G CrucialC 2 Replies Last reply
                4
                • mariner4lifeM mariner4life

                  @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                  @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                  @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                  I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                  I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                  Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                  that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                  gt12G Offline
                  gt12G Offline
                  gt12
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #209

                  @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                  @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                  @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                  @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                  I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                  I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                  Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                  that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                  He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                  mariner4lifeM 1 Reply Last reply
                  0
                  • gt12G gt12

                    @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                    @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                    @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                    @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                    I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                    I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                    Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                    that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                    He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                    mariner4lifeM Offline
                    mariner4lifeM Offline
                    mariner4life
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #210

                    @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                    @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                    @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                    @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                    @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                    I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                    I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                    Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                    that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                    He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                    we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                    gt12G 1 Reply Last reply
                    0
                    • mariner4lifeM mariner4life

                      @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                      @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                      @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                      I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                      I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                      Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                      that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                      CrucialC Offline
                      CrucialC Offline
                      Crucial
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #211

                      @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                      @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                      @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                      @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                      I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                      I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                      Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                      that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                      True. Look at MMac's play for the Chiefs last year. He was the best option they had and once the style was adjusted so that it didn't rely on creativity from 10 they did Ok. He steered them around and sat back when the tempo increased so that others could take advantage.
                      A better option than throwing a green youngster with potential into the critical position.

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      1
                      • BovidaeB Offline
                        BovidaeB Offline
                        Bovidae
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #212

                        MMac did led Taranaki to an NPC title but he had major weaknesses, the most obvious being a poor defender. He was also an inconsistent goal kicker.

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        0
                        • antipodeanA Offline
                          antipodeanA Offline
                          antipodean
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #213

                          MMac's major problem is the talent wasn't evenly distributed in his family.

                          1 Reply Last reply
                          2
                          • mariner4lifeM mariner4life

                            @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                            I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                            I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                            Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                            that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                            He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                            we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                            gt12G Offline
                            gt12G Offline
                            gt12
                            wrote on last edited by gt12
                            #214

                            @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                            @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                            I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                            I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                            Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                            that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                            He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                            we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                            Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                            My personal feeling is that beyond the star power he had (Cruden, SBW, Cane, Messam, then Retallick), it was the squad selections by Rennie and his team that paid off. Horrell, Tiks, Sona, Robinson (fitting given that they are cousins) were all players who could come in and fill a role in alignment with strategy.

                            With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                            mariner4lifeM CrucialC 2 Replies Last reply
                            1
                            • gt12G gt12

                              @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                              I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                              I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                              Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                              that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                              He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                              we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                              Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                              My personal feeling is that beyond the star power he had (Cruden, SBW, Cane, Messam, then Retallick), it was the squad selections by Rennie and his team that paid off. Horrell, Tiks, Sona, Robinson (fitting given that they are cousins) were all players who could come in and fill a role in alignment with strategy.

                              With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                              mariner4lifeM Offline
                              mariner4lifeM Offline
                              mariner4life
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #215

                              @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                              @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                              I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                              I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                              Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                              that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                              He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                              we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                              Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                              My personal feeling is that beyond the star power he had (Cruden, SBW, Cane, then Retallick), it was the squad selections by Rennie and his team that paid off. Horrell, Tiks, Sona, Robinson (fitting given that they are cousins) were all players who could come in and fill a rule in alignment with strategy.

                              With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                              Rennie was pretty good at getting guys to play above themselves as well. Gave them a role in the side, and focused them on being really good at that

                              1 Reply Last reply
                              0
                              • gt12G Offline
                                gt12G Offline
                                gt12
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #216

                                I guess the other thing about those teams were that we had AB or close to AB quality in key positions: Hooker, lock, flankers (2), hb, first five, midfield, and fb.

                                I’ll look forward to seeing who they roll out today.

                                mariner4lifeM 1 Reply Last reply
                                1
                                • gt12G gt12

                                  @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                                  I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                                  I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                                  Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                                  that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                                  He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                                  we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                                  Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                                  My personal feeling is that beyond the star power he had (Cruden, SBW, Cane, Messam, then Retallick), it was the squad selections by Rennie and his team that paid off. Horrell, Tiks, Sona, Robinson (fitting given that they are cousins) were all players who could come in and fill a role in alignment with strategy.

                                  With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                                  CrucialC Offline
                                  CrucialC Offline
                                  Crucial
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #217

                                  @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                                  @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                                  I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                                  I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                                  Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                                  that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                                  He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                                  we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                                  Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                                  With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                                  What lesson? He was a squad filler and a fallback, not predicted to be a starter or main component.
                                  The point I was trying to make was that this type of player is quickly dissed around here but what is the alternative you offer? Where is the queue of gun 10s that will set the tournament alight? The ones that Cooper should have added to the squad instead of MMac?
                                  They had the young guys in there for development but they got injured and the 'safety' option had to be deployed. He was a good option in that situation is all I am saying. I don't think anyone, including Cooper, has ever seen him as a gun.
                                  In retrospect the Blues, with their perennial issues in the position probably could have done with a 'glue' 10 and built the style around that. Get into position then strike instead of expecting a flaky 'skills' option to create a win for you. Would it have won them titles? No, but it probably would have won them more games than searching for something that wasn't there.

                                  mariner4lifeM BovidaeB gt12G 3 Replies Last reply
                                  4
                                  • gt12G gt12

                                    I guess the other thing about those teams were that we had AB or close to AB quality in key positions: Hooker, lock, flankers (2), hb, first five, midfield, and fb.

                                    I’ll look forward to seeing who they roll out today.

                                    mariner4lifeM Offline
                                    mariner4lifeM Offline
                                    mariner4life
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #218

                                    @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                    I guess the other thing about those teams were that we had AB or close to AB quality in key positions: Hooker, lock, flankers (2), hb, first five, midfield, and fb.

                                    I’ll look forward to seeing who they roll out today.

                                    it was a seriously good side, especially at loose forward.

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    0
                                    • CrucialC Crucial

                                      @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                      @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                      @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                      @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                      @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                                      @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                                      @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                                      I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                                      I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                                      Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                                      that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                                      He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                                      we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                                      Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                                      With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                                      What lesson? He was a squad filler and a fallback, not predicted to be a starter or main component.
                                      The point I was trying to make was that this type of player is quickly dissed around here but what is the alternative you offer? Where is the queue of gun 10s that will set the tournament alight? The ones that Cooper should have added to the squad instead of MMac?
                                      They had the young guys in there for development but they got injured and the 'safety' option had to be deployed. He was a good option in that situation is all I am saying. I don't think anyone, including Cooper, has ever seen him as a gun.
                                      In retrospect the Blues, with their perennial issues in the position probably could have done with a 'glue' 10 and built the style around that. Get into position then strike instead of expecting a flaky 'skills' option to create a win for you. Would it have won them titles? No, but it probably would have won them more games than searching for something that wasn't there.

                                      mariner4lifeM Offline
                                      mariner4lifeM Offline
                                      mariner4life
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #219

                                      @Crucial we're very light at 10 across the whole country. And that includes the starters, let alone the backups.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      2
                                      • CrucialC Crucial

                                        @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                        @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                        @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                        @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                        @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                                        @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                                        @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                                        I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                                        I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                                        Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                                        that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                                        He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                                        we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                                        Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                                        With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                                        What lesson? He was a squad filler and a fallback, not predicted to be a starter or main component.
                                        The point I was trying to make was that this type of player is quickly dissed around here but what is the alternative you offer? Where is the queue of gun 10s that will set the tournament alight? The ones that Cooper should have added to the squad instead of MMac?
                                        They had the young guys in there for development but they got injured and the 'safety' option had to be deployed. He was a good option in that situation is all I am saying. I don't think anyone, including Cooper, has ever seen him as a gun.
                                        In retrospect the Blues, with their perennial issues in the position probably could have done with a 'glue' 10 and built the style around that. Get into position then strike instead of expecting a flaky 'skills' option to create a win for you. Would it have won them titles? No, but it probably would have won them more games than searching for something that wasn't there.

                                        BovidaeB Offline
                                        BovidaeB Offline
                                        Bovidae
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #220

                                        @Crucial Agree with that summary. In the Chiefs first game Cooper started Leger at 1st 5 because all the other options were injured. Debreczeni would have been their choice to play there when DMac was moved but he had a couple of false starts too.

                                        1 Reply Last reply
                                        1
                                        • CrucialC Crucial

                                          @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                                          I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                                          I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                                          Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                                          that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                                          He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                                          we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                                          Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                                          With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                                          What lesson? He was a squad filler and a fallback, not predicted to be a starter or main component.
                                          The point I was trying to make was that this type of player is quickly dissed around here but what is the alternative you offer? Where is the queue of gun 10s that will set the tournament alight? The ones that Cooper should have added to the squad instead of MMac?
                                          They had the young guys in there for development but they got injured and the 'safety' option had to be deployed. He was a good option in that situation is all I am saying. I don't think anyone, including Cooper, has ever seen him as a gun.
                                          In retrospect the Blues, with their perennial issues in the position probably could have done with a 'glue' 10 and built the style around that. Get into position then strike instead of expecting a flaky 'skills' option to create a win for you. Would it have won them titles? No, but it probably would have won them more games than searching for something that wasn't there.

                                          gt12G Offline
                                          gt12G Offline
                                          gt12
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #221

                                          @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @gt12 said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @mariner4life said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @Crucial said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @Yeetyaah said in Chiefs 2020:

                                          @Crucial experience, yes. Skills, debatable.

                                          I said solid skills not outstanding skills.

                                          I think that our high standards in looking for the exceptional in players in NZ often make us blind or overly critical to players with very good basic skill levels that would be welcome in many clubs around the world.
                                          Anscombe and Gopperth are a couple of examples of guys that have done much better for themselves finding an environment that desires basics rather than pushing too hard for the exceptional.

                                          that is a fair point, we, as fans, have gone away from valuing "glue" players. If a bloke isn't a potential AB, we are already looking for the replacement.

                                          He wasn’t an Andrew Horrell though, that’s exactly the problem with him - reasonable goal kicking aside, he has short distance kicking with the boot, is slow as fuck, and is not a great passer - making him the perfect back up first five for Chiefs rugby. Thanks Colin!

                                          we had more holes than just Marty. Our squad was pretty ordinary.

                                          Agreed, but he just wasn’t quite good enough.

                                          With Cooper it seemed to be, I know him from Taranaki, good man, that’ll do. I hope that lesson has been learned....

                                          What lesson? He was a squad filler and a fallback, not predicted to be a starter or main component.
                                          The point I was trying to make was that this type of player is quickly dissed around here but what is the alternative you offer? Where is the queue of gun 10s that will set the tournament alight? The ones that Cooper should have added to the squad instead of MMac?
                                          They had the young guys in there for development but they got injured and the 'safety' option had to be deployed. He was a good option in that situation is all I am saying. I don't think anyone, including Cooper, has ever seen him as a gun.
                                          In retrospect the Blues, with their perennial issues in the position probably could have done with a 'glue' 10 and built the style around that. Get into position then strike instead of expecting a flaky 'skills' option to create a win for you. Would it have won them titles? No, but it probably would have won them more games than searching for something that wasn't there.

                                          You do like to move the goal posts don't you? I'm not looking for a 'gun' and that wasn't my argument; I'm asking the coaches to sign and look at guys beyond the ones they know and like.

                                          MMac was picked (again) in 2018 as the third first five, which isn't so bad, until you consider that the Crusaders got rid of him and signed Mike Delany instead.

                                          So, we brought back their cast off and didn't pursue other options, such as Hayden Parker, who was coming back from injury and wasn't re-signed (at that point, I believe), so went overseas.

                                          He could have been an AB had we invested in him then.

                                          The landers also had Fletcher Smith, who would end up behind Sopoaga and Josh Ioane.

                                          CrucialC 1 Reply Last reply
                                          1
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Search
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Search