All Blacks 2021
-
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2021:
@mariner4life i agree 100%, just in the AB's thread i kind of change the focus to what would have been good, wouldn't suggest it in the super thread or a team one
my point was more you have it backwards. the same guys aren't getting games that stifle development of a young gun, the same inadequate guys are getting a run because there is no one better coming through demanding selection. It's the same in a number of positions, most notably 10, where there is precisely one international standard 10 in the country.
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2021:
@kiwiwomble said in All Blacks 2021:
@mariner4life i agree 100%, just in the AB's thread i kind of change the focus to what would have been good, wouldn't suggest it in the super thread or a team one
my point was more you have it backwards. the same guys aren't getting games that stifle development of a young gun, the same inadequate guys are getting a run because there is no one better coming through demanding selection. It's the same in a number of positions, most notably 10, where there is precisely one international standard 10 in the country.
Fair point. There have been a number of good prospects coming into SR at 10 but they seem to stagnate or end up switched to another position, Josh Ioane being a good example.
You wonder if there's a bit more dialogue needed between the AB management and the SR franchises on player development.
-
I'm warming to Christie, he's finally improving and I thought last weekend was probably the best I've seen him play. Would be interesting to see what he could learn off Smith in camp.
Ennor, not so much. Roane, PUJ, Faingaanuku should all be ahead of him.
-
@african-monkey LOL. God damn that would almost be worth it for the thread.
@tim said in All Blacks 2021:
@african-monkey LOL. God damn that would almost be worth it for the thread.
Total meltdown!
-
I'm warming to Christie, he's finally improving and I thought last weekend was probably the best I've seen him play. Would be interesting to see what he could learn off Smith in camp.
Ennor, not so much. Roane, PUJ, Faingaanuku should all be ahead of him.
-
I'm warming to Christie, he's finally improving and I thought last weekend was probably the best I've seen him play. Would be interesting to see what he could learn off Smith in camp.
Ennor, not so much. Roane, PUJ, Faingaanuku should all be ahead of him.
@bones said in All Blacks 2021:
I'm warming to Christie, he's finally improving and I thought last weekend was probably the best I've seen him play. Would be interesting to see what he could learn off Smith in camp.
Ennor, not so much. Roane, PUJ, Faingaanuku should all be ahead of him.
He’s definitely been playing better than Weber. And he was in the AB frame before being injured.
-
@bones I'm not sold on him (thought his best game was v the Brumbies)
I'll be surprised if we dont see Smith, TJ & Webber named as the 3 9s (if Fozzie wants TJ, he will be there)
@taniwharugby yeah my criticisms are he's not a great reader of the game and can be very frenetic, making his pass inconsistent. Often slows the ruck delivery down when it's crying out for a quick feed.
Can't fault his fitness and application though.
-
@taniwharugby yeah my criticisms are he's not a great reader of the game and can be very frenetic, making his pass inconsistent. Often slows the ruck delivery down when it's crying out for a quick feed.
Can't fault his fitness and application though.
@bones I think he has made good strides with consistent selection in the past month or so, but still not at the level I expect from someone I'd like to see in the ABs.
-
@antipodean I'll laugh harder if Finlay Christie gets in.
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2021:
@antipodean I'll laugh harder if Finlay Christie gets in.
Not sure I agree with you on that one
-
@stargazer Well Jonathan Ruru didn't get a Maori call up so my guess is that he will be the 3rd AB halfback.....
@african-monkey said in All Blacks 2021:
@stargazer Well Jonathan Ruru didn't get a Maori call up so my guess is that he will be the 3rd AB halfback.....
Funniest post of the year.
-
@Stargazer just further to that who would you pick as halfbacks?
@booboo Aaron Smith, Brad Weber and - now that Bryn Hall has been picked for the MABs - I'd probably get TJP in the squad, despite him officially not being eligible. During the July Series, I'd also get Folau Fakatava in to observe and learn (he can work on his rehab under their supervision).
-
@booboo Aaron Smith, Brad Weber and - now that Bryn Hall has been picked for the MABs - I'd probably get TJP in the squad, despite him officially not being eligible. During the July Series, I'd also get Folau Fakatava in to observe and learn (he can work on his rehab under their supervision).
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2021:
@booboo Aaron Smith, Brad Weber and - now that Bryn Hall has been picked for the MABs - I'd probably get TJP in the squad, despite him officially not being eligible. During the July Series, I'd also get Folau Fakatava in to observe and learn (he can work on his rehab under their supervision).
Let's assume that Hall has missed his window (shame because he's capable) and TJP is not available, coz I'm pretty sure he's not .. . Who then?
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2021:
@booboo Aaron Smith, Brad Weber and - now that Bryn Hall has been picked for the MABs - I'd probably get TJP in the squad, despite him officially not being eligible. During the July Series, I'd also get Folau Fakatava in to observe and learn (he can work on his rehab under their supervision).
Let's assume that Hall has missed his window (shame because he's capable) and TJP is not available, coz I'm pretty sure he's not .. . Who then?
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2021:
@booboo Probably Drummond.
That would underwhelm me massively.
Christie would be a mulch better option.
But frankly my choice at No.3 No.9 (given Hall old, TJP unavailable, Fakatava injured) would be T-cubed. But don't see that happening.
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2021:
@booboo Probably Drummond.
Good god, no. Super rugby is his ceiling.
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2021:
@booboo Probably Drummond.
Good god, no. Super rugby is his ceiling.
@kirwan said in All Blacks 2021:
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2021:
@booboo Probably Drummond.
Good god, no. Super rugby is his ceiling.
He's got a pretty similar game to TJP on attack. Although that was a bit pants last year.
-
Christie is slow as shit. Should be no where near the ABs. Weber and 2020 TJP were both awful too.
-
@tim yeah Christie and Drummond would cause cardiologists around NZ to be on high alert. Both have massive “work ons” and that’s putting it kindly.
Just go back to TTT or give the Northland fella a go.
@act-crusader said in All Blacks 2021:
@tim yeah Christie and Drummond would cause cardiologists around NZ to be on high alert. Both have massive “work ons” and that’s putting it kindly.
Just go back to TTT or give the Northland fella a go.
Fakatava would be my choice TTT has done nothing, Hall sucks behind a poor pack, Drummond has known for poor option taking and Christie depends on his mood.
-
Christie is slow as shit. Should be no where near the ABs. Weber and 2020 TJP were both awful too.
