Skip to content
  • Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

  • Tipping
  • Team Sheets
  • Highlights
  • Results
    • All Blacks

      Search every All Blacks Test. Filter results by year, opposition, location, venue, city and RWC stage

    • Super Rugby

      Search every Super Rugby since match 1996

    • NPC

      Search NPC results. Only first division matches from 1976-2005. All results from the 14 team competition (2006-present) are included

Foster, Robertson etc

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Sports Talk
allblacks
5.7k Posts 131 Posters 759.8k Views 3 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • taniwharugbyT taniwharugby

    @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

    Dan54D Offline
    Dan54D Offline
    Dan54
    wrote on last edited by
    #3941

    @taniwharugby said in Foster:

    @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

    Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

    ChrisC 1 Reply Last reply
    0
    • Dan54D Dan54

      @taniwharugby said in Foster:

      @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

      Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

      ChrisC Offline
      ChrisC Offline
      Chris
      wrote on last edited by
      #3942

      @Dan54 said in Foster:

      @taniwharugby said in Foster:

      @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

      Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

      And trust me being a coach professionally you need a big ego.

      NepiaN 1 Reply Last reply
      1
      • antipodeanA antipodean

        @MiketheSnow why does Llanelli bang on about this like the All Blacks had never lost a midweek fixture before?

        That 72 tour was a pretty average team.

        MiketheSnowM Offline
        MiketheSnowM Offline
        MiketheSnow
        wrote on last edited by
        #3943

        @antipodean said in Foster:

        @MiketheSnow why does Llanelli bang on about this like the All Blacks had never lost a midweek fixture before?

        That 72 tour was a pretty average team.

        Because our national team couldn’t do it in our heyday with all our stars

        1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • CrucialC Crucial

          @kiwi_expat said in All Blacks vs Wales:

          @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

          @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

          the cupboard is very bare at 12

          I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

          Ngani would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

          Wow. Imagine how good Charlie Ngatai would have been under this saviour!

          What is it that people see as Razor's best attribute? Is it the water to wine thing or the water walking?

          Victor MeldrewV Offline
          Victor MeldrewV Offline
          Victor Meldrew
          wrote on last edited by
          #3944

          @Crucial said in Foster:

          What is it that people see as Razor's best attribute? Is it the water to wine thing or the water walking?

          His ability to get many of his supporters use overblown hyperbole when discussing him?

          CrucialC 1 Reply Last reply
          7
          • Victor MeldrewV Victor Meldrew

            @Crucial said in Foster:

            What is it that people see as Razor's best attribute? Is it the water to wine thing or the water walking?

            His ability to get many of his supporters use overblown hyperbole when discussing him?

            CrucialC Offline
            CrucialC Offline
            Crucial
            wrote on last edited by
            #3945

            @Victor-Meldrew said in Foster:

            @Crucial said in Foster:

            What is it that people see as Razor's best attribute? Is it the water to wine thing or the water walking?

            His ability to get many of his supporters use overblown hyperbole when discussing him?

            Well he has turned a number of players into ABs despite a lack of talent and it has been taking a while for those that count to notice.

            1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • KiwiMurphK Offline
              KiwiMurphK Offline
              KiwiMurph
              wrote on last edited by
              #3946

              @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

              @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

              @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

              the cupboard is very bare at 12

              I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

              Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

              I call bullshit.

              Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

              No QuarterN 1 Reply Last reply
              8
              • ChrisC Chris

                @Dan54 said in Foster:

                @taniwharugby said in Foster:

                @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

                Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

                And trust me being a coach professionally you need a big ego.

                NepiaN Offline
                NepiaN Offline
                Nepia
                wrote on last edited by
                #3947

                @Chris said in Foster:

                @Dan54 said in Foster:

                @taniwharugby said in Foster:

                @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

                Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

                And trust me being a coach professionally you need a big ego.

                If you don't have a big one, like Rennie, you'll bring in a guy like Smith and then you'll have numpties on a forum attributing your success to him for years afterwards. 😉

                ChrisC kiwi_expatK 2 Replies Last reply
                1
                • NepiaN Nepia

                  @Chris said in Foster:

                  @Dan54 said in Foster:

                  @taniwharugby said in Foster:

                  @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

                  Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

                  And trust me being a coach professionally you need a big ego.

                  If you don't have a big one, like Rennie, you'll bring in a guy like Smith and then you'll have numpties on a forum attributing your success to him for years afterwards. 😉

                  ChrisC Offline
                  ChrisC Offline
                  Chris
                  wrote on last edited by Chris
                  #3948

                  @Nepia said in Foster:

                  @Chris said in Foster:

                  @Dan54 said in Foster:

                  @taniwharugby said in Foster:

                  @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

                  Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

                  And trust me being a coach professionally you need a big ego.

                  If you don't have a big one, like Rennie, you'll bring in a guy like Smith and then you'll have numpties on a forum attributing your success to him for years afterwards. 😉

                  More about needing a big ego to deal with players outside influences and Nuffies( the Aussie term)
                  Than being smart enough to get the right team around you .

                  1 Reply Last reply
                  1
                  • KiwiMurphK KiwiMurph

                    @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                    @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                    @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                    the cupboard is very bare at 12

                    I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                    Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                    I call bullshit.

                    Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                    No QuarterN Offline
                    No QuarterN Offline
                    No Quarter
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #3949

                    @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                    @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                    @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                    @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                    the cupboard is very bare at 12

                    I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                    Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                    I call bullshit.

                    Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                    Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                    MiketheSnowM A MN5M 3 Replies Last reply
                    0
                    • No QuarterN No Quarter

                      @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                      @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                      @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                      @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                      the cupboard is very bare at 12

                      I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                      Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                      I call bullshit.

                      Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                      Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                      MiketheSnowM Offline
                      MiketheSnowM Offline
                      MiketheSnow
                      wrote on last edited by
                      #3950

                      @No-Quarter said in Foster:

                      @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                      @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                      @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                      @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                      the cupboard is very bare at 12

                      I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                      Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                      I call bullshit.

                      Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                      Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                      This is an often underappreciated (simply not understood) aspect of great coaches

                      Knowing where a player's ability ceiling is

                      How many times have we seen club / provincial superstars not cut it at Test level

                      And conversely solid club / provincial players who've flourished at Test level (often because they can concentrate just on their own game)

                      1 Reply Last reply
                      2
                      • kiwi_expatK kiwi_expat

                        @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                        @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                        the cupboard is very bare at 12

                        I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                        Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                        Victor MeldrewV Offline
                        Victor MeldrewV Offline
                        Victor Meldrew
                        wrote on last edited by
                        #3951

                        @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                        @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                        @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                        the cupboard is very bare at 12

                        I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                        Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                        Absolutely. Unlike Foster who continually buggers up world-class players like George Bridge

                        1 Reply Last reply
                        2
                        • NepiaN Nepia

                          @Chris said in Foster:

                          @Dan54 said in Foster:

                          @taniwharugby said in Foster:

                          @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

                          Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

                          And trust me being a coach professionally you need a big ego.

                          If you don't have a big one, like Rennie, you'll bring in a guy like Smith and then you'll have numpties on a forum attributing your success to him for years afterwards. 😉

                          kiwi_expatK Offline
                          kiwi_expatK Offline
                          kiwi_expat
                          wrote on last edited by kiwi_expat
                          #3952

                          @Nepia said in Foster:

                          @Chris said in Foster:

                          @Dan54 said in Foster:

                          @taniwharugby said in Foster:

                          @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

                          Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

                          And trust me being a coach professionally you need a big ego.

                          If you don't have a big one, like Rennie, you'll bring in a guy like Smith and then you'll have numpties on a forum attributing your success to him for years afterwards. 😉

                          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Rennie#Wallabies

                          38% record from 30 test matches!

                          Rennie had pretty limited success without W.Smith at the Chiefs, he then underachieved considerably with a very strong Glasgow squad that he inherited from Toonie, which had been dominating in the years prior, and had won the Pro14 that previous season.

                          It isn't a niche view that Wayne Smith was the key influence towards the Chiefs 2 titles, he was the team's Strategist and game-planner, oversaw the attack, hands on with his other pet area of defense/counter-attack, his fingerprints were everywhere, it was patently obvious to see.

                          Dan54D 1 Reply Last reply
                          4
                          • kiwi_expatK kiwi_expat

                            @Nepia said in Foster:

                            @Chris said in Foster:

                            @Dan54 said in Foster:

                            @taniwharugby said in Foster:

                            @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

                            Yep think it could be called ego to taniwha! Why I suspect maybe we wouldn't get a Joseph/Razor combo either, not sure who would be prepared to be assistant.

                            And trust me being a coach professionally you need a big ego.

                            If you don't have a big one, like Rennie, you'll bring in a guy like Smith and then you'll have numpties on a forum attributing your success to him for years afterwards. 😉

                            https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dave_Rennie#Wallabies

                            38% record from 30 test matches!

                            Rennie had pretty limited success without W.Smith at the Chiefs, he then underachieved considerably with a very strong Glasgow squad that he inherited from Toonie, which had been dominating in the years prior, and had won the Pro14 that previous season.

                            It isn't a niche view that Wayne Smith was the key influence towards the Chiefs 2 titles, he was the team's Strategist and game-planner, oversaw the attack, hands on with his other pet area of defense/counter-attack, his fingerprints were everywhere, it was patently obvious to see.

                            Dan54D Offline
                            Dan54D Offline
                            Dan54
                            wrote on last edited by
                            #3953

                            @kiwi_expat Yep, and you just have to read how hard Hansen worked to get him to comeback for 2015 WC, says in the end Smith's wife asked Hansen's missus to just let him go after 15! Interesting that Foster says he got Schmodt's missus to give him the fianl push to make himself available, as they were pretty good mates etc.. Hansen also says in his book that NZR tried for Schmidt after 19 WC, but he just needed a break as he was struggling mentally a bit.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            1
                            • taniwharugbyT taniwharugby

                              @Dan54 I think the prep in in terms of managing player load, game plans for players, specific to opposition and tactics, exploiting weaknesses, I mean the Super Rugby final was case in point...but the key part to this all, is getting them to execute the plan, and this is where Foster seems to come unstuck...which is where maybe if Razor had been willing to work under Foster, at least initially, maybe Fosters vision (cos he clearly must have something he is wanting to achieve) with Razors prep and planning would have been something special, but I can understand why Razor didnt want this, as he certainly seems to march to his own beat.

                              dogmeatD Offline
                              dogmeatD Offline
                              dogmeat
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #3954

                              @taniwharugby Robertson might be good at managing workload to suit the Crusaders but there has been plenty of criticism that he has flogged players (SW is the oft quoted example) to the detriment of the AB's i.e. nothing left in the tank by the time the international season rolls round.

                              Now looking after the AB's isn't his (current) gig but it is another factor an international coach has to cope with that a Super rugby one doesn't.

                              F 1 Reply Last reply
                              4
                              • dogmeatD dogmeat

                                @taniwharugby Robertson might be good at managing workload to suit the Crusaders but there has been plenty of criticism that he has flogged players (SW is the oft quoted example) to the detriment of the AB's i.e. nothing left in the tank by the time the international season rolls round.

                                Now looking after the AB's isn't his (current) gig but it is another factor an international coach has to cope with that a Super rugby one doesn't.

                                F Offline
                                F Offline
                                Frye
                                wrote on last edited by Frye
                                #3955

                                @dogmeat said in Foster:

                                @taniwharugby Robertson might be good at managing workload to suit the Crusaders but there has been plenty of criticism that he has flogged players (SW is the oft quoted example) to the detriment of the AB's i.e. nothing left in the tank by the time the international season rolls round.

                                Now looking after the AB's isn't his (current) gig but it is another factor an international coach has to cope with that a Super rugby one doesn't.

                                Player workloads are an inexact science. The NZRU set strict limits on how many minutes All Blacks can play during the super season and all Robertson has to do is to abide by those limits. Which he does.

                                It's absurd to suggest Razor should be able to tell in March or April or something, forsee six months into the future, and know that one of his players might be not be performing at an optimal level in November.

                                If players are getting "flogged" (which honestly they're not) then it's clearly up to the NZRU, or the ABs, or Nic Gill or whoever to reevaluate those limits. It's not on Robertson to go above and beyond for a team that he's not even directly accountable for.

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                5
                                • No QuarterN No Quarter

                                  @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                                  @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                                  @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                  @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                  the cupboard is very bare at 12

                                  I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                                  Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                                  I call bullshit.

                                  Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                                  Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                                  A Offline
                                  A Offline
                                  akan004
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #3956

                                  @No-Quarter said in Foster:

                                  @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                                  @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                                  @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                  @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                  the cupboard is very bare at 12

                                  I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                                  Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                                  I call bullshit.

                                  Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                                  Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                                  Was he that big or powerful though? Certainly not at test level. I can't recall him bending the line like Nonu used to. In fact Jordie looked far more physical and powerful against Australia than Laumape ever did in the black jersey.

                                  Rancid SchnitzelR No QuarterN 2 Replies Last reply
                                  7
                                  • A akan004

                                    @No-Quarter said in Foster:

                                    @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                                    @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                                    @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                    @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                    the cupboard is very bare at 12

                                    I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                                    Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                                    I call bullshit.

                                    Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                                    Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                                    Was he that big or powerful though? Certainly not at test level. I can't recall him bending the line like Nonu used to. In fact Jordie looked far more physical and powerful against Australia than Laumape ever did in the black jersey.

                                    Rancid SchnitzelR Offline
                                    Rancid SchnitzelR Offline
                                    Rancid Schnitzel
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #3957

                                    @akan004 said in Foster:

                                    @No-Quarter said in Foster:

                                    @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                                    @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                                    @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                    @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                    the cupboard is very bare at 12

                                    I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                                    Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                                    I call bullshit.

                                    Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                                    Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                                    Was he that big or powerful though? Certainly not at test level. I can't recall him bending the line like Nonu used to. In fact Jordie looked far more physical and powerful against Australia than Laumape ever did in the black jersey.

                                    Laumape's neither as bad as his detractors make out nor nearly as good as his supporters claim. He's an absolute nugget of a man and would be a nightmare to defend against, but he seemed to be fairly effectively shut down at test level. He's certainly no Nonu.

                                    canefanC 1 Reply Last reply
                                    5
                                    • No QuarterN No Quarter

                                      @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                                      @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                                      @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                      @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                      the cupboard is very bare at 12

                                      I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                                      Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                                      I call bullshit.

                                      Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                                      Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                                      MN5M Offline
                                      MN5M Offline
                                      MN5
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #3958

                                      @No-Quarter said in Foster:

                                      @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                                      @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                                      @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                      @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                      the cupboard is very bare at 12

                                      I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                                      Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                                      I call bullshit.

                                      Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                                      Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                                      Na that would be George Moala ( going back a few more years )

                                      He was a taller Nonu basically with every bit of the brick shithouseness.

                                      1 Reply Last reply
                                      1
                                      • A akan004

                                        @No-Quarter said in Foster:

                                        @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                                        @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                                        @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                        @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                        the cupboard is very bare at 12

                                        I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                                        Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                                        I call bullshit.

                                        Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                                        Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                                        Was he that big or powerful though? Certainly not at test level. I can't recall him bending the line like Nonu used to. In fact Jordie looked far more physical and powerful against Australia than Laumape ever did in the black jersey.

                                        No QuarterN Offline
                                        No QuarterN Offline
                                        No Quarter
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #3959

                                        @akan004 said in Foster:

                                        @No-Quarter said in Foster:

                                        @KiwiMurph said in Foster:

                                        @kiwi_expat said in Foster:

                                        @nzzp said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                        @No-Quarter said in All Blacks vs Wales:

                                        the cupboard is very bare at 12

                                        I still reckon that a well coached Laumape could have been a bloody good 12 at Test level. Just never got his head right at that level I don't think.

                                        Laumape would've fulfilled his potential under Razor, he would've extracted the best out of him for All Blacks.

                                        I call bullshit.

                                        Laumape's game didn't translate to test footy.

                                        Laumape had all the skills - strong, quick, could kick and pass, purely from a physical attributes POV he's the closest we've had to Nonu. What he lacked was the top two inches, just never had the vision to be successful at the top level so was pretty easily shut down. Fantastic at Super level though.

                                        Was he that big or powerful though? Certainly not at test level. I can't recall him bending the line like Nonu used to. In fact Jordie looked far more physical and powerful against Australia than Laumape ever did in the black jersey.

                                        Yeah he's one of those players that looked big and powerful at Super level but then was shut down pretty easily at test level. I think it shows you need more than just power to be successful the next level up. All of my 'wrecking ball' memories of him are in a Canes jumper really.

                                        Even with Nonu, he would just waltz through players at Super level, but had to be a lot smarter at test level knowing when to pick his moments, which is why it took him a while to find his feet. In the end he just had such amazing vision to go with his physical attributes.

                                        kiwiinmelbK 1 Reply Last reply
                                        4
                                        • KiwiMurphK Offline
                                          KiwiMurphK Offline
                                          KiwiMurph
                                          wrote on last edited by KiwiMurph
                                          #3960

                                          I think Nonu gets unfairly labelled as a bash and crash merchant but people forget he had wonderful footwork and vision in his running - that was evident right from when he burst on the scene playing wing for Canes in 03 (and obviously this got better and better and more refined as his career went on - especially from 08 onwards).

                                          canefanC Victor MeldrewV 2 Replies Last reply
                                          6
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Search
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Search