All Blacks 2023
-
@African-Monkey said in All Blacks 2023:
Looks like Christie has overtaken Frizell as the ferns most hated AB, slightly ahead of Caleb Clarke currently.
Codie Taylor has shown them the path they need to tread
@Bones said in All Blacks 2023:
@African-Monkey said in All Blacks 2023:
Looks like Christie has overtaken Frizell as the ferns most hated AB, slightly ahead of Caleb Clarke currently.
Codie Taylor has shown them the path they need to tread
Codie is born again hard. He's coming good at just the right time
-
Looks like Christie has overtaken Frizell as the ferns most hated AB, slightly ahead of Caleb Clarke currently.
@African-Monkey said in All Blacks 2023:
Looks like Christie has overtaken Frizell as the ferns most hated AB, slightly ahead of Caleb Clarke currently.
A noisy minority.
-
So I ordered my 11 year old daughter a RWC shirt. Think the cartoonish design is perfect for kids even if I won’t touch it myself. I’ve got a polo with proper embroidered logos so will hang onto that as long as possible.
-
I'm going, sounds good to me! Hopefully Christie gets a start though, I've heard he's amazing live.
@Bones said in All Blacks 2023:
I'm going, sounds good to me! Hopefully Christie gets a start though, I've heard he's amazing live.
He's great - gives you plenty of time to analyse his decision-making.
-
Looks like Christie has overtaken Frizell as the ferns most hated AB, slightly ahead of Caleb Clarke currently.
@African-Monkey said in All Blacks 2023:
Looks like Christie has overtaken Frizell as the ferns most hated AB, slightly ahead of Caleb Clarke currently.
I actually thought he was pretty good against the Boks. But both times he's started, he's not been good.
-
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
-
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2023:
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
Not sure it's fair to TJP to compare him to Christie....
-
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2023:
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
I think perhaps it's why they pick him? If you want to play a different style? I also think Roigard is pretty different style too.
-
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2023:
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
Not sure it's fair to TJP to compare him to Christie....
@canefan said in All Blacks 2023:
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2023:
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
Not sure it's fair to TJP to compare him to Christie....
I had concerns over TJp in his early years , seemed a bit loose between the ears
-
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2023:
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
I think perhaps it's why they pick him? If you want to play a different style? I also think Roigard is pretty different style too.
-
Christie isn' a bad player, I like him but wouldn't pick him as he's just so different in style to Smith that it makes no sense selecting him because the whole game changes in your key decision-making positions. Same was true of Perenara of course.
I think he's OK closing out a game and his D is excellent, but he struggles starting at 9.
Not that it's likely, but would be interesting to see Christie starting behind the A pack. He got a lot of stick from Bled 2 but the forwards were pretty much under the pump in the first 20.
-
-
I think he's OK closing out a game and his D is excellent, but he struggles starting at 9.
Not that it's likely, but would be interesting to see Christie starting behind the A pack. He got a lot of stick from Bled 2 but the forwards were pretty much under the pump in the first 20.
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
I think he's OK closing out a game and his D is excellent, but he struggles starting at 9.
Not that it's likely, but would be interesting to see Christie starting behind the A pack. He got a lot of stick from Bled 2 but the forwards were pretty much under the pump in the first 20.
He's not a bad player, and I agree his defence is very good and he can close out games if we're ahead. But I care about attack and want an option on the bench that either fits in to the rapid style seamlessly, or adds something / gives us a different approach if we're in trouble. At some point we're likely to be behind with 20 to go, and Foster will bring Christie on, and our chances of winning will diminish because a good defensive player isn't always what is required, plus slower service making it harder for others to attack. Not just Christie either, I reckon our use of the bench has become really ordinary.
-
I think he's OK closing out a game and his D is excellent, but he struggles starting at 9.
Not that it's likely, but would be interesting to see Christie starting behind the A pack. He got a lot of stick from Bled 2 but the forwards were pretty much under the pump in the first 20.
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
D is excellent
Not sure I buy that.
He seems to be a very good tackler for a halfback, but that doesn't necessarily make him an excellent defender.
-
@Tim said in All Blacks 2023:
https://www.rugbypass.com/news/jordie-barrett-details-physical-transformation-for-midfield-switch/
A little while back, we were trying to guess his weight,
105 kgs
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2023:
D is excellent
Not sure I buy that.
He seems to be a very good tackler for a halfback, but that doesn't necessarily make him an excellent defender.
I re-watched the last 20 mins of the Bokke Test and thought his anticipation and tackling were both very good. Sadly, almost the opposite of his anticipation on attack and his speed of passing...
I'd prefer Weber - or Roigard with a few games under his belt - though
