RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy
-
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
Foster has always preferred Taylor, even when it was blindingly obvious that he was playing terribly and Samisoni was playing great. IIRC he dropped Samisoni despite being our best forward for the Irish decider, then continued using Taylor while our lineout and his general play was dogshit all last season. Taylor is a decent player, but his form last year was arguably the worst I've seen an AB get away with and keep being selected - and that's not when the cupboard was bare, but when we had another option who was clearly better. It is just shit selection.
Samisoni should be a bolted on starter by now. Taylor or Coles should be the bench guy, or if we were better at handling young players, Aumua could have been ready in time.
We all sit around bemoaning Super rugby and our lack of grunt up front - and we have that guy right fucking there and they won't fucking pick him! -
I agree with the many posters hoping to see a more direct game.
Given Matt Carly is ref - the stars are aligned for the ABs to stumble , fall foul of the officials etc., ill-discipline will be costly - not just for this match .. I hope the ABs don't stumble over this banana peel of a game -
All I want is some simple disciplined rugby, play for territory, value and contest possessions, strong defense and put some doubt in the minds of those who have already written the ABs off........ (Please no Foster and BB hold my beer moments)
-
O'Gara thinks the ABs can "surprise people and go all the way" if they are "more aggressive with their 'D'". So he obviously thinks the standard of cattle is good enough
Given he has experienced NZ rugby, he knows the quality NZ possess. The quip about the 'D' is a dig towards the coaches. I remember he had similar conversations with Robertson and the Crusaders players in his time there about moving them away from man-watching to ball-watching. -
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
Foster has always preferred Taylor, even when it was blindingly obvious that he was playing terribly and Samisoni was playing great. IIRC he dropped Samisoni despite being our best forward for the Irish decider, then continued using Taylor while our lineout and his general play was dogshit all last season. Taylor is a decent player, but his form last year was arguably the worst I've seen an AB get away with and keep being selected - and that's not when the cupboard was bare, but when we had another option who was clearly better. It is just shit selection.
Samisoni should be a bolted on starter by now. Taylor or Coles should be the bench guy, or if we were better at handling young players, Aumua could have been ready in time.
We all sit around bemoaning Super rugby and our lack of grunt up front - and we have that guy right fucking there and they won't fucking pick him!@reprobate said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
Foster has always preferred Taylor, even when it was blindingly obvious that he was playing terribly and Samisoni was playing great. IIRC he dropped Samisoni despite being our best forward for the Irish decider, then continued using Taylor while our lineout and his general play was dogshit all last season. Taylor is a decent player, but his form last year was arguably the worst I've seen an AB get away with and keep being selected - and that's not when the cupboard was bare, but when we had another option who was clearly better. It is just shit selection.
Samisoni should be a bolted on starter by now. Taylor or Coles should be the bench guy, or if we were better at handling young players, Aumua could have been ready in time.
We all sit around bemoaning Super rugby and our lack of grunt up front - and we have that guy right fucking there and they won't fucking pick him!If what you say is true - and it may be - you have to question what value Ryan actually adds, don't you?
-
Italy will set out to play defensively, we know that. They won't do anything risky, until maybe at the end if they are chasing the game.
If Italy kick to Beauden Barrett repeatedly, they might win the kicking duel, which will leave the ABs with poor field position, and then hope for penalties.
We might try taking it up the guts, but we have recently had a tendency to drop the ball when we do that. If we crab across field, then yuck. We might kick for position, but that has never really been a Foster strategy.
So it will come down to whether our scrum and lineout will hold up. If they fail, it will be hard going.
I expect the ABs to win, but we have really struggled in recent years when teams have defended stubbornly. We will rely, as ever, on individual brilliance.
-
Italy will set out to play defensively, we know that. They won't do anything risky, until maybe at the end if they are chasing the game.
If Italy kick to Beauden Barrett repeatedly, they might win the kicking duel, which will leave the ABs with poor field position, and then hope for penalties.
We might try taking it up the guts, but we have recently had a tendency to drop the ball when we do that. If we crab across field, then yuck. We might kick for position, but that has never really been a Foster strategy.
So it will come down to whether our scrum and lineout will hold up. If they fail, it will be hard going.
I expect the ABs to win, but we have really struggled in recent years when teams have defended stubbornly. We will rely, as ever, on individual brilliance.
@Chester-Draws said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
We will rely, as ever, on individual brilliance.
It's the Late Hansen & Foster way. Sadly
-
Italy will set out to play defensively, we know that. They won't do anything risky, until maybe at the end if they are chasing the game.
If Italy kick to Beauden Barrett repeatedly, they might win the kicking duel, which will leave the ABs with poor field position, and then hope for penalties.
We might try taking it up the guts, but we have recently had a tendency to drop the ball when we do that. If we crab across field, then yuck. We might kick for position, but that has never really been a Foster strategy.
So it will come down to whether our scrum and lineout will hold up. If they fail, it will be hard going.
I expect the ABs to win, but we have really struggled in recent years when teams have defended stubbornly. We will rely, as ever, on individual brilliance.
The closer the game is the more concerned I am about it. Not sure why as it should be a comfortable win for us but I just have a nagging feeling about this game for some reason.
-
There will be a high of 30 degrees tomorrow in Lyon. I’m amazed it is still that hot at this time of year (UK feels like autumn already!)
I hope this doesn’t lead Fozzie into overuse of a kicking game to preserve players.
While on paper we should beat Italy comfortably, we know world cups are different and I believe Italy will have been targeting this game for some time.
They have improved a lot of the last year and will love the opportunity of a knockout match against the All Blacks.
I want to see us tighten our game up, play direct with ball in hand, kick well but not just for the sake of it and put down a marker to show that they are capable of going deep in this tournament.
Discipline needs to be spot on as this ref could blow us off the park if we are not at our best and a red card could mean the end of our World Cup.
There is an article on the herald stating the ABs are being ignored with no one turning up to press conferences etc and are literally not regarded as a threat. I want to see that change by tomorrow night.
@DaGrubster said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
I hope this doesn’t lead Fozzie into overuse of a kicking game to preserve players.
stats show kicking is a big part of games in recent times, which I thnk we are in line with others, its just the amount of times we fuck around in our own 22 and/or half with short kicks that creates undue pressure on ourselves.
As I have said, kick and chase game being improved will help immensely, harder to fix though is our discipline, this aspect will be more crucial against tougher opposition, but lest start by improving drastically v Italy
-
The closer the game is the more concerned I am about it. Not sure why as it should be a comfortable win for us but I just have a nagging feeling about this game for some reason.
@DaGrubster said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
The closer the game is the more concerned I am about it. Not sure why as it should be a comfortable win for us but I just have a nagging feeling about this game for some reason.
a feeling of impending doom.......
-
@DaGrubster said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
I hope this doesn’t lead Fozzie into overuse of a kicking game to preserve players.
stats show kicking is a big part of games in recent times, which I thnk we are in line with others, its just the amount of times we fuck around in our own 22 and/or half with short kicks that creates undue pressure on ourselves.
As I have said, kick and chase game being improved will help immensely, harder to fix though is our discipline, this aspect will be more crucial against tougher opposition, but lest start by improving drastically v Italy
@taniwharugby said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@DaGrubster said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
I hope this doesn’t lead Fozzie into overuse of a kicking game to preserve players.
stats show kicking is a big part of games in recent times, which I thnk we are in line with others, its just the amount of times we fuck around in our own 22 and/or half with short kicks that creates undue pressure on ourselves.
As I have said, kick and chase game being improved will help immensely, harder to fix though, our disipline, this aspect is more crucial against tougher opposition.
99% of that is BB
-
-
@DaGrubster said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
The closer the game is the more concerned I am about it. Not sure why as it should be a comfortable win for us but I just have a nagging feeling about this game for some reason.
a feeling of impending doom.......
@Mattasaurus said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@DaGrubster said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
The closer the game is the more concerned I am about it. Not sure why as it should be a comfortable win for us but I just have a nagging feeling about this game for some reason.
a feeling of impending doom.......
Foster said that statistic meant nothing ahead of Friday’s clash.
“History means nothing,” he added. “History is yesterday’s newspaper, isn’t it, not tomorrow’s.”
-
What odds are other sites offering on this game?
Obviously TAB have us all but unbackable faves.
TAB has us at $1.01 and Italy at $15, and even $2.25 to simply lead at any time.
NZ 1-12 @ $5
NZ 13+ @ $1.12
Points start at -31.5 for $1.87. -
What odds are other sites offering on this game?
Obviously TAB have us all but unbackable faves.
TAB has us at $1.01 and Italy at $15, and even $2.25 to simply lead at any time.
NZ 1-12 @ $5
NZ 13+ @ $1.12
Points start at -31.5 for $1.87.@taniwharugby said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
What odds are other sites offering on this game?
sportsbet has us at $1.01 and Italy at $19.
NZ 1-7 @ $15
NZ 8-14@ $8.75
NZ 15+ @ $1.12
Points start at -28.5 for $1.86 -
@reprobate said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
Foster has always preferred Taylor, even when it was blindingly obvious that he was playing terribly and Samisoni was playing great. IIRC he dropped Samisoni despite being our best forward for the Irish decider, then continued using Taylor while our lineout and his general play was dogshit all last season. Taylor is a decent player, but his form last year was arguably the worst I've seen an AB get away with and keep being selected - and that's not when the cupboard was bare, but when we had another option who was clearly better. It is just shit selection.
Samisoni should be a bolted on starter by now. Taylor or Coles should be the bench guy, or if we were better at handling young players, Aumua could have been ready in time.
We all sit around bemoaning Super rugby and our lack of grunt up front - and we have that guy right fucking there and they won't fucking pick him!If what you say is true - and it may be - you have to question what value Ryan actually adds, don't you?
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@reprobate said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
Foster has always preferred Taylor, even when it was blindingly obvious that he was playing terribly and Samisoni was playing great. IIRC he dropped Samisoni despite being our best forward for the Irish decider, then continued using Taylor while our lineout and his general play was dogshit all last season. Taylor is a decent player, but his form last year was arguably the worst I've seen an AB get away with and keep being selected - and that's not when the cupboard was bare, but when we had another option who was clearly better. It is just shit selection.
Samisoni should be a bolted on starter by now. Taylor or Coles should be the bench guy, or if we were better at handling young players, Aumua could have been ready in time.
We all sit around bemoaning Super rugby and our lack of grunt up front - and we have that guy right fucking there and they won't fucking pick him!If what you say is true - and it may be - you have to question what value Ryan actually adds, don't you?
Not really. Foster's preference for Taylor and Taylor's terrible form pre-dates Ryan being involved.
Has Ryan changed that? No. Has he tried? No idea.
Buck stops with the head coach. -
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@reprobate said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
Foster has always preferred Taylor, even when it was blindingly obvious that he was playing terribly and Samisoni was playing great. IIRC he dropped Samisoni despite being our best forward for the Irish decider, then continued using Taylor while our lineout and his general play was dogshit all last season. Taylor is a decent player, but his form last year was arguably the worst I've seen an AB get away with and keep being selected - and that's not when the cupboard was bare, but when we had another option who was clearly better. It is just shit selection.
Samisoni should be a bolted on starter by now. Taylor or Coles should be the bench guy, or if we were better at handling young players, Aumua could have been ready in time.
We all sit around bemoaning Super rugby and our lack of grunt up front - and we have that guy right fucking there and they won't fucking pick him!If what you say is true - and it may be - you have to question what value Ryan actually adds, don't you?
Not really. Foster's preference for Taylor and Taylor's terrible form pre-dates Ryan being involved.
Has Ryan changed that? No. Has he tried? No idea.
Buck stops with the head coach.@reprobate said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@reprobate said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
Foster has always preferred Taylor, even when it was blindingly obvious that he was playing terribly and Samisoni was playing great. IIRC he dropped Samisoni despite being our best forward for the Irish decider, then continued using Taylor while our lineout and his general play was dogshit all last season. Taylor is a decent player, but his form last year was arguably the worst I've seen an AB get away with and keep being selected - and that's not when the cupboard was bare, but when we had another option who was clearly better. It is just shit selection.
Samisoni should be a bolted on starter by now. Taylor or Coles should be the bench guy, or if we were better at handling young players, Aumua could have been ready in time.
We all sit around bemoaning Super rugby and our lack of grunt up front - and we have that guy right fucking there and they won't fucking pick him!If what you say is true - and it may be - you have to question what value Ryan actually adds, don't you?
Not really. Foster's preference for Taylor and Taylor's terrible form pre-dates Ryan being involved.
Has Ryan changed that? No. Has he tried? No idea.
Buck stops with the head coach.So you're now also saying the Head coach and not the Forwards coach deserves the credit when the forwards are going well?
-
@Victor-Meldrew said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
@Tim said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Poor coaching, as is the standard.
Same coaching set-up when he was getting game-time and being so bloody effective coming off the bench. Weird.
Foster has always preferred Taylor, even when it was blindingly obvious that he was playing terribly and Samisoni was playing great. IIRC he dropped Samisoni despite being our best forward for the Irish decider, then continued using Taylor while our lineout and his general play was dogshit all last season. Taylor is a decent player, but his form last year was arguably the worst I've seen an AB get away with and keep being selected - and that's not when the cupboard was bare, but when we had another option who was clearly better. It is just shit selection.
Samisoni should be a bolted on starter by now. Taylor or Coles should be the bench guy, or if we were better at handling young players, Aumua could have been ready in time.
We all sit around bemoaning Super rugby and our lack of grunt up front - and we have that guy right fucking there and they won't fucking pick him!@reprobate said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Aumua could have been ready in time
Aumua's big problem - that kept him out of the ABs, esp. since ST was picked - was his very poor line-out throwing. He got his chances, but didn't take them. It was only last year that he improved his line-out throwing. Injuries have played a role, too.
Anyway, if Aumua had been considered for the RWC squad, it would have been a choice between him and Coles.
-
Ritchie being out injured may be the tried and true Foster approaching to improving his team (being forced to change selections by injury).
We aren't winning the world cup with Ritchie Mounga at 10. might as well try DMac.
@Kirwan said in RWC Week 4: All Blacks v Italy:
Ritchie being out injured may be the tried and true Foster approaching to improving his team (being forced to change selections by injury).
We aren't winning the world cup with Ritchie Mounga at 10. might as well try DMac.
Is he confirmed out? I can’t find anything
️?
