All Blacks 2024
-
@Bones said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Chris-B probably looking for versatility, hello McNicholl, Springer and Reece.
McNicholl ineligible?
-
@Bones said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Chris-B probably looking for versatility, hello McNicholl, Springer and Reece.
McNicholl ineligible?
@MiketheSnow said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Chris-B probably looking for versatility, hello McNicholl, Springer and Reece.
McNicholl ineligible?
Last capped for Wales in 2022 so yes he’s ineligible. Wouldn’t be considered to get a call up at 33 years old anyway, especially as an outside back.
-
@MiketheSnow said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Chris-B probably looking for versatility, hello McNicholl, Springer and Reece.
McNicholl ineligible?
Last capped for Wales in 2022 so yes he’s ineligible. Wouldn’t be considered to get a call up at 33 years old anyway, especially as an outside back.
@Landers92 said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@MiketheSnow said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Chris-B probably looking for versatility, hello McNicholl, Springer and Reece.
McNicholl ineligible?
Last capped for Wales in 2022 so yes he’s ineligible. Wouldn’t be considered to get a call up at 33 years old anyway, especially as an outside back.
In fairness he’s looking better as a Crusader than he did as a Scarlet
-
@Bones said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Chris-B probably looking for versatility, hello McNicholl, Springer and Reece.
McNicholl ineligible?
@MiketheSnow said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Chris-B probably looking for versatility, hello McNicholl, Springer and Reece.
McNicholl ineligible?
Ok I didn't think I'd need to clarify, but there was absolutely zero seriousness in my post.
-
@Kirwan said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Between Ardie and Barrett, yikes. Not exactly the two sharpest knives in the drawer.
Most likely Scooter. Has the mana and the time to grow as captain.
If the likes of Pat T and/or Cane are selected, there'd be enough experience around him to call on.
-
@Kirwan said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Between Ardie and Barrett, yikes. Not exactly the two sharpest knives in the drawer.
Most likely Scooter. Has the mana and the time to grow as captain.
If the likes of Pat T and/or Cane are selected, there'd be enough experience around him to call on.
@Victor-Meldrew said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Most likely Scooter.
Because of Robertson?
I don't think Scott has even close to the charisma needed right now. He comes across as a bit boring. At a time when NZR maybe needs someone who offers a bit more.
And maybe another Crusader is becoming a bit much.
-
@Kirwan said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
McCaw was a great captain, but dull as dishwater. This ain’t Eurovision.
my view is McCaw was miles better than Scott. But rugby needs to recognise it's in the entertainment business. We need more dynamic leaders that especially resonate's with a younger audience. My view is Ardie does much better than Scott.
But it's possible Ardie wouldn't want the job
There's also the PI factor. Add some diversity
-
@Kirwan said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
McCaw was a great captain, but dull as dishwater. This ain’t Eurovision.
my view is McCaw was miles better than Scott. But rugby needs to recognise it's in the entertainment business. We need more dynamic leaders that especially resonate's with a younger audience. My view is Ardie does much better than Scott.
But it's possible Ardie wouldn't want the job
There's also the PI factor. Add some diversity
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
-
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023. Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023. Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023.
I dunno.... there didn't look to be that much space in the DeLorean to me....
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023. Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023. Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
Dalton - only if Razor rates his game.
Sami - dropped off a cliff, and hookers are often replaced
Props aren't great captaincy choices and again often get replaced. -
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023. Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
He's not even rated no1 for the Blues.
WE really haven't got an obvious candidate at present. I would go for Ardie as a Umaga type appointment. Not a long-term appointment but the best there is now. Definitely not Scott. Some might underestimate the importance of the other factors. In this day and age rugby in this country can continue its decline. Or start doing something a bit different to try and grab back a (much) bigger audience.
-
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023. Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
Dalton - only if Razor rates his game.
Sami - dropped off a cliff, and hookers are often replaced
Props aren't great captaincy choices and again often get replaced.@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Dalton - only if Razor rates his game.
think it was 2022 when Dalton looked for all money future AB captain, his leadership in the blues was evident, more so when he wasnt there.
But the argument is less strong now, although I expect he would certainly grow into it.
-
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Dalton - only if Razor rates his game.
think it was 2022 when Dalton looked for all money future AB captain, his leadership in the blues was evident, more so when he wasnt there.
But the argument is less strong now, although I expect he would certainly grow into it.
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
But the argument is less strong now, although I expect he would certainly grow into it.
unless they picked Patty to free Dalton up for the ABs.
CONSPIRACY THEORY TIME! RAZOR IS SECRETLY AN AUCKLANDER TRANSPLANTED TO THE BAY. BELIEVE EVERYTHING I WRITE IT'S IN CAPS AND I RESEARCHED IT ON FACEBOOK.
-
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
He's not even rated no1 for the Blues.
WE really haven't got an obvious candidate at present. I would go for Ardie as a Umaga type appointment. Not a long-term appointment but the best there is now. Definitely not Scott. Some might underestimate the importance of the other factors. In this day and age rugby in this country can continue its decline. Or start doing something a bit different to try and grab back a (much) bigger audience.
@Winger said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
He's not even rated no1 for the Blues.
Wasn’t an issue for Fitzpatrick, if my memory serves me right. Wasn’t Zinzan the Auckland captain when Fitzy was AB captain?
-
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023. Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
Dalton - only if Razor rates his game.
Sami - dropped off a cliff, and hookers are often replaced
Props aren't great captaincy choices and again often get replaced.@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@nzzp said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger Disagree completely.
I'd have no problem with Ardie, but for different reasons.
All Blacks get eyeballs because they win. Having a captain that cna influence refs is their core role. The rest is fluff. Leadership can come from VC or seniors in the squad. Diversity and entertainment are secondary to the core role.
If I were Razor, I'd be asking- for locked in starters:
- Who can influence refs at the top level the best (or learn to, like McCaw)
- Are any of them credible 4 year captains?
then I'd be looking at media skills, diversity, entertainment, etc.
Very few get past step 1. How many 4 year candidates are there? I suspect SBar, Rieko, Jordie and then you're scratching around.
Papali'i, Taukei'aho, De Groot and Lomax are probably the others you'd bank on being there in 2023. Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
Dalton - only if Razor rates his game.
Sami - dropped off a cliff, and hookers are often replaced
Props aren't great captaincy choices and again often get replaced.Think dropped off a cliff is a major overstatement. Other than Aumua, he's still been the best and most consistent NZ hooker throughout Super Rugby this year.
Agree that hookers and props are often replaced and aren't necessarily great captaincy options, was more just commenting on the fact that they're likely to be around for the long-term. I don't think Ioane is a good captaincy option either.
-
@Winger said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
He's not even rated no1 for the Blues.
Wasn’t an issue for Fitzpatrick, if my memory serves me right. Wasn’t Zinzan the Auckland captain when Fitzy was AB captain?
@Gunner said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
He's not even rated no1 for the Blues.
Wasn’t an issue for Fitzpatrick, if my memory serves me right. Wasn’t Zinzan the Auckland captain when Fitzy was AB captain?
Yep, they did they to take some work off his plate.
-
@Gunner said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
He's not even rated no1 for the Blues.
Wasn’t an issue for Fitzpatrick, if my memory serves me right. Wasn’t Zinzan the Auckland captain when Fitzy was AB captain?
Yep, they did they to take some work off his plate.
@Kirwan said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Gunner said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Winger said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024 - looking forward:
Papali'i is a pretty feasible option in my mind.
He's not even rated no1 for the Blues.
Wasn’t an issue for Fitzpatrick, if my memory serves me right. Wasn’t Zinzan the Auckland captain when Fitzy was AB captain?
Yep, they did they to take some work off his plate.
My conspiracy is that is the reason why Paps isn’t captain this year.
We’ve had different AB and Super captains quite a bit. I think McCaw wasn’t captain at times for the Saders (or has dementia finally hit?)
