All Blacks 2024
-
@NTA said in All Blacks 2024:
@stodders said in All Blacks 2024:
@NTA Nick, what's your opinion on the lost Wallaby talent that is Tyrel Lomax?
Good prop. Wish he was still on this side of the ditch. I think he'd go better with our locks than yours.
He went all right against Ox and the Boks pack with Vaa'i behind him, apart from a couple of scrums. And ABs had upper hand by end of H1 in Cape Town. Even better against England with Paddy T.
LSL is good scrummaging LH lock. Is Frost top dog of the local TH locks?
@pakman said in All Blacks 2024:
LSL is good scrummaging LH lock. Is Frost top dog of the local TH locks?
I think LSL actually has the mongrel to do both.
Frost is a big lad and important to securing scrum ball.
Williams has surprised me - he's not the biggest but he's very capable and handy around the park as well.
Potentially Skelton in the mix on EOYT as we toss up opening the borders in preparation for Lions 2025.
-
I agree with all of that - except the last two cards Cane received for the AB's were in the first half so he shouldn't be fatigued. Maybe he was? ¯_(ツ)_/¯
An interesting write up here which includes some footage of some of Cane's missed tackles - though not the ones that lead directly to tries.
@brodean Yeah I've read that. You could easily pick and choose moments from games this year to make Savea or any other AB pretty much look like a retard too, so I'm not a big fan of the cherry-picking game moments type of article.
A hard man and a legend for coming back from a broken neck - but Cane's well and truly done in my eyes, we can't have a tight forward playing in the AB 7 shirt, no matter how loose our 8 is.
-
@pakman said in All Blacks 2024:
LSL is good scrummaging LH lock. Is Frost top dog of the local TH locks?
I think LSL actually has the mongrel to do both.
Frost is a big lad and important to securing scrum ball.
Williams has surprised me - he's not the biggest but he's very capable and handy around the park as well.
Potentially Skelton in the mix on EOYT as we toss up opening the borders in preparation for Lions 2025.
@NTA said in All Blacks 2024:
@pakman said in All Blacks 2024:
LSL is good scrummaging LH lock. Is Frost top dog of the local TH locks?
I think LSL actually has the mongrel to do both.
Frost is a big lad and important to securing scrum ball.
Williams has surprised me - he's not the biggest but he's very capable and handy around the park as well.
Potentially Skelton in the mix on EOYT as we toss up opening the borders in preparation for Lions 2025.
Agree on LSL.
Will keep an eye out on Frost.
Will/Nella is a helluva lot of beef!
-
@SBW1 said in All Blacks 2024:
@SBW1 Saw this today, Frizzel and Mounga are being chased.
Why are we chasing these proven failures?
-
@Victor-Meldrew and with the sub system available now players can get experience without compromising results.
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2024:
@Victor-Meldrew and with the sub system available now players can get experience without compromising results.
By not scoring points in the final 20mins?
-
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
-
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
No, because he's gone to Japan and seemingly indicated he's going to switch right back to league if he can't get selected for the All Blacks out of Japan - which is never going to happen for a multitude of reasons.
-
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
No, because he's gone to Japan and seemingly indicated he's going to switch right back to league if he can't get selected for the All Blacks out of Japan - which is never going to happen for a multitude of reasons.
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024:
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
No, because he's gone to Japan and seemingly indicated he's going to switch right back to league if he can't get selected for the All Blacks out of Japan - which is never going to happen for a multitude of reasons.
Ok , beaver on senz reckons after Japan he is going to the chiefs .
-
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024:
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
No, because he's gone to Japan and seemingly indicated he's going to switch right back to league if he can't get selected for the All Blacks out of Japan - which is never going to happen for a multitude of reasons.
Ok , beaver on senz reckons after Japan he is going to the chiefs .
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024:
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
No, because he's gone to Japan and seemingly indicated he's going to switch right back to league if he can't get selected for the All Blacks out of Japan - which is never going to happen for a multitude of reasons.
Ok , beaver on senz reckons after Japan he is going to the chiefs .
To be fair, I might be slightly misremembering what I've read.
But until he signs for an NZ team (or indicates he'd like to play in NZ), he's probably not going to be on many people's radars.
-
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024:
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
No, because he's gone to Japan and seemingly indicated he's going to switch right back to league if he can't get selected for the All Blacks out of Japan - which is never going to happen for a multitude of reasons.
Ok , beaver on senz reckons after Japan he is going to the chiefs .
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024:
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
No, because he's gone to Japan and seemingly indicated he's going to switch right back to league if he can't get selected for the All Blacks out of Japan - which is never going to happen for a multitude of reasons.
Ok , beaver on senz reckons after Japan he is going to the chiefs .
I guess that means 2026?
Looking at the fixtures the start of the Japanese season is late Dec and the final is played at the begining of June
-
I disagree on that because currently we have good depth in props and locks the most important positions in the team. We can take on anyone and have a good chance with the right headspace attitude.
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2024:
I disagree on that because currently we have good depth in props and locks the most important positions in the team. We can take on anyone and have a good chance with the right headspace attitude.
Yea but also right the game plan.
If our tight is our strength at the moment, why are we still seeking to play a wide game that exposes our slow back row, “flaky” first five, “sub-par” centre pairing, and slow back three? Why are we not playing to the areas of strength in our team? Are we too proud to use our scrum to bludgeon the opposition and win territory and points? Or are we just deluding ourselves that we still have the best talent in the world across the park?
*By “we” I’m really referring to the coaching team
-
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
@Mr-Fish said in All Blacks 2024:
@kiwiinmelb said in All Blacks 2024:
Probably not the right thread, but I’m not sure where else to ask , I guess he is a potential future AB so it’s a bit related .
Has there been much interest in nz with Joey manu switching to rugby ? And the questions about what level he can go to , and what position he would play etc ?
No, because he's gone to Japan and seemingly indicated he's going to switch right back to league if he can't get selected for the All Blacks out of Japan - which is never going to happen for a multitude of reasons.
Ok , beaver on senz reckons after Japan he is going to the chiefs .
I guess that means 2026?
Looking at the fixtures the start of the Japanese season is late Dec and the final is played at the begining of June
-
Manu is on a 1 year deal. He wants to try for the AB’s so to do that he would need to be in NZ as the rules currently stand. He will be learning his craft around some of the best - Aaron Smith, Beauden Barrett, Ian Foster and Steve Hansen. Some pretty good guys to be rubbing shoulders with.
-
phenomenal rugby league centre. Great running game, skillful offload game.
Obvious rugby league body height issues on both sides of the ball. Not a great passing game. Doesn't have high end pace.
Worst of all he's 28. That's very long in the tooth to be changing up and hoping to make test grade. Chances of him being anymore than a "lets see if we can make this work" AB squaddie are very very low.
-
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2024:
I disagree on that because currently we have good depth in props and locks the most important positions in the team. We can take on anyone and have a good chance with the right headspace attitude.
Yea but also right the game plan.
If our tight is our strength at the moment, why are we still seeking to play a wide game that exposes our slow back row, “flaky” first five, “sub-par” centre pairing, and slow back three? Why are we not playing to the areas of strength in our team? Are we too proud to use our scrum to bludgeon the opposition and win territory and points? Or are we just deluding ourselves that we still have the best talent in the world across the park?
*By “we” I’m really referring to the coaching team
@junior said in All Blacks 2024:
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2024:
I disagree on that because currently we have good depth in props and locks the most important positions in the team. We can take on anyone and have a good chance with the right headspace attitude.
Yea but also right the game plan.
If our tight is our strength at the moment, why are we still seeking to play a wide game that exposes our slow back row, “flaky” first five, “sub-par” centre pairing, and slow back three? Why are we not playing to the areas of strength in our team? Are we too proud to use our scrum to bludgeon the opposition and win territory and points? Or are we just deluding ourselves that we still have the best talent in the world across the park?
*By “we” I’m really referring to the coaching team
pretty damning we cant come up with different gameplans to compliment our strengths
-
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2024:
I disagree on that because currently we have good depth in props and locks the most important positions in the team. We can take on anyone and have a good chance with the right headspace attitude.
Yea but also right the game plan.
If our tight is our strength at the moment, why are we still seeking to play a wide game that exposes our slow back row, “flaky” first five, “sub-par” centre pairing, and slow back three? Why are we not playing to the areas of strength in our team? Are we too proud to use our scrum to bludgeon the opposition and win territory and points? Or are we just deluding ourselves that we still have the best talent in the world across the park?
*By “we” I’m really referring to the coaching team
@junior said in All Blacks 2024:
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2024:
I disagree on that because currently we have good depth in props and locks the most important positions in the team. We can take on anyone and have a good chance with the right headspace attitude.
Yea but also right the game plan.
If our tight is our strength at the moment, why are we still seeking to play a wide game that exposes our slow back row, “flaky” first five, “sub-par” centre pairing, and slow back three? Why are we not playing to the areas of strength in our team? Are we too proud to use our scrum to bludgeon the opposition and win territory and points? Or are we just deluding ourselves that we still have the best talent in the world across the park?
*By “we” I’m really referring to the coaching team
It's not our strength, really. We have good props and hookers, but not great. They'll at least hold their own against anyone, but they won't bully top teams. Locks? Same deal at best. Vaai has stepped up, but Barrett is the only proven one and he's a bit on the short side.
Our points of difference vs the top teams are guys like McKenzie, Jordan, Clarke. -
Did anyone else watch the full interview with Ryan on the Aotearoa pod? Some good stuff there but also a very worrying acceptance and explaining away of test losses. I find it amazing that it hasn't been brought up - they talk about the ABs against the Boks as if we are a development team, just accepting the two losses as ‘we had an opportunity to win both games’.
I’m very concerned about the fact that they are relying on Cane to set standards. What are the coaches and management team doing?
-
Did anyone else watch the full interview with Ryan on the Aotearoa pod? Some good stuff there but also a very worrying acceptance and explaining away of test losses. I find it amazing that it hasn't been brought up - they talk about the ABs against the Boks as if we are a development team, just accepting the two losses as ‘we had an opportunity to win both games’.
I’m very concerned about the fact that they are relying on Cane to set standards. What are the coaches and management team doing?
@gt12 said in All Blacks 2024:
Did anyone else watch the full interview with Ryan on the Aotearoa pod? Some good stuff there but also a very worrying acceptance and explaining away of test losses. I find it amazing that it has been brought up - they talk about the ABs against the Boks as if we are a development team, just accepting the two losses as ‘we had an opportunity to win both games’.
I’m very concerned about the fact that they are relying on Cane to set standards. What are the coaches and management team doing?
I agree it's concerning and I also think Cane is the wrong guy to set standards. He's been very inconsistent during the 20s
