All Blacks 2022
-
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
Enari and Nankivell putting their hands up in this match.
Nankivell not so much. Rocks and diamonds...
One rock!
Uhm:
@bones said in Chiefs vs Moana Pasifika:
Nankivell is shit
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
Enari and Nankivell putting their hands up in this match.
Nankivell not so much. Rocks and diamonds...
One rock!
Uhm:
@bones said in Chiefs vs Moana Pasifika:
Nankivell is shit
Lies
-
@crazy-horse said in All Blacks 2022:
While I don't necessarily disagree with this, but according to the Fern a first 15 AB team would arguably only have Whitelock, Jordan and possibly Reece from the Crusaders. Yet, they have been the bench mark as a team for the last few years and last night the Blues scraped home. Somebody must be doing something right. Coaching? A team being better than the sum of its parts?
Good coaching, sure (I’d be happy with Razor as AB coach with the right assistants).
But also some players are good at Super level and don’t make the step up.
Add in talent is spread around the country, one on one matchups change the make up too.
Final thing to consider is players like Taylor might be going backwards individually, or at least being overtaken. Just because the Crusaders as a team are playing well doesn’t mean all their players get in the All Blacks.
That’s more a feather in the coaching groups cap. Individual selection then factors in form and the ability or potential to play Test rugby. And some players, like Bridge, have been tried and found wanting.
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
Enari and Nankivell putting their hands up in this match.
Nankivell not so much. Rocks and diamonds...
One rock!
Uhm:
@bones said in Chiefs vs Moana Pasifika:
Nankivell is shit
Lies
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones said in All Blacks 2022:
Enari and Nankivell putting their hands up in this match.
Nankivell not so much. Rocks and diamonds...
One rock!
Uhm:
@bones said in Chiefs vs Moana Pasifika:
Nankivell is shit
Lies
-
@mr-fish said in All Blacks 2022:
@bones Etene Nanai-Seturo or Ereatara Enari?
Ummm.... the guy who's name I wrote...
-
- Aaron
- Beaudy
- Clarke
- Jordie
- Rieko
- Reece
- Jordan
That's a starting backline I want to see. Power, size, speed and elusiveness. Reece is easily the best right wing in New Zealand. Jordan is too good not to start at fullback where he can get more opportunities. Clarke is the form left winger. Rieko is the form centre and has pace to burn. Aaron's pass can ensure Beaudy can run into space and if he needs to bail out, Jordie has the size and skillset to get over the advantage line.
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2022:
- Aaron
- Beaudy
- Clarke
- Jordie
- Rieko
- Reece
- Jordan
That's exactly the backline I was thinking about when I posted my comment just before your post.
-
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2022:
- Aaron
- Beaudy
- Clarke
- Jordie
- Rieko
- Reece
- Jordan
That's exactly the backline I was thinking about when I posted my comment just before your post.
-
I'm seriously worried about our playmakers.
Both BB and RM last night showed serious flaws for test level. BB still relies on moments of brilliance (as does RM) but showed zero tactical awareness and control. I'm not just talking about the last 10 minutes either. When he did try to play tactically his skills (in particular kicking from hand) really let him down.
RM just isn't up to it defensively and if you can't hide him (or the opposition seek him out) it is 2019 semifinal all over again.@crucial said in All Blacks 2022:
I'm seriously worried about our playmakers.
Both BB and RM last night showed serious flaws for test level. BB still relies on moments of brilliance (as does RM) but showed zero tactical awareness and control. I'm not just talking about the last 10 minutes either. When he did try to play tactically his skills (in particular kicking from hand) really let him down.
RM just isn't up to it defensively and if you can't hide him (or the opposition seek him out) it is 2019 semifinal all over again.Yes, both seriously gifted but just as limited players. We have to find a way that utilises both their strengths and nullifies their glaring weaknesses. I still think this means having one start and one finish, as it is clear now that having them both on the field at the same time only plays to their weak points rather than their strengths.
-
Gotta say I would love to see J Savea come back and have a go at that try scoring record.
-
Looking over the stats from last night, it's interesting reading, Mo'unga apparently only missed one tackle (made 3, missed 1), but it was a try conceding tackle and would be on that would interest international coaches (as @Crucial mentioned above).
Havili had a pretty good game on one side of the ball with a beautiful pass for a try assist, 7 runs, 3 defenders beaten, and 1 offload,. However, he missed 4 tackles (made 5) and I would say that international coaches will be examining those. I remember one was being stepped by Barrett but I think a couple of the others were related to the big runners coming down his channel (hope someone does a rewatch).
I think the point made above about defending in the line is a reasonable one for discussion, Barrett missed 3 tackles last night and made 2, but many here would argue that he is still a more effective defender that Mo'unga. For me, his shit kicking from hand and 4 turnovers were a problem, although one of those was a knock on that would have been a try if he regathered.
I also see that they've updated the tackle stats - Paps had 23 made, zero missed.
like numbers for a guy who also got around the field so well. Given his size, we might be able to get away with Savea at 8 in a Rodders role if Paps can be the tackle machine and ball runner that Richie became during that time.@gt12 said in All Blacks 2022:
Looking over the stats from last night, it's interesting reading, Mo'unga apparently only missed one tackle (made 3, missed 1), but it was a try conceding tackle and would be on that would interest international coaches (as @Crucial mentioned above).
Havili had a pretty good game on one side of the ball with a beautiful pass for a try assist, 7 runs, 3 defenders beaten, and 1 offload,. However, he missed 4 tackles (made 5) and I would say that international coaches will be examining those. I remember one was being stepped by Barrett but I think a couple of the others were related to the big runners coming down his channel (hope someone does a rewatch).
I think the point made above about defending in the line is a reasonable one for discussion, Barrett missed 3 tackles last night and made 2, but many here would argue that he is still a more effective defender that Mo'unga. For me, his shit kicking from hand and 4 turnovers were a problem, although one of those was a knock on that would have been a try if he regathered.
I also see that they've updated the tackle stats - Paps had 23 made, zero missed.
like numbers for a guy who also got around the field so well. Given his size, we might be able to get away with Savea at 8 in a Rodders role if Paps can be the tackle machine and ball runner that Richie became during that time.That also means we need a Jerry Collins equivalent in the 6 - buggered if i know who that might be
-
@gt12 as pointed out at the time, Hall with the assist on that miss on DP...RM may have held DP leg slowing him for the cover but as Hall came over he fell on RM meaning he couldn't hold on.
@taniwharugby said in All Blacks 2022:
@gt12 as pointed out at the time, Hall with the assist on that miss on DP...RM may have held DP leg slowing him for the cover but as Hall came over he fell on RM meaning he couldn't hold on.
The Eklund try also demonstrated Mounga's lack of size and strength in the tackle. I am not criticising Mounga here because he was in position and did make the tackle. I am merely pointing out that physics is a thing and you can imagine teams will try run big guys down his channel close to the line because they know they will have a very good chance of getting over.
-
@gt12 said in All Blacks 2022:
Looking over the stats from last night, it's interesting reading, Mo'unga apparently only missed one tackle (made 3, missed 1), but it was a try conceding tackle and would be on that would interest international coaches (as @Crucial mentioned above).
Havili had a pretty good game on one side of the ball with a beautiful pass for a try assist, 7 runs, 3 defenders beaten, and 1 offload,. However, he missed 4 tackles (made 5) and I would say that international coaches will be examining those. I remember one was being stepped by Barrett but I think a couple of the others were related to the big runners coming down his channel (hope someone does a rewatch).
I think the point made above about defending in the line is a reasonable one for discussion, Barrett missed 3 tackles last night and made 2, but many here would argue that he is still a more effective defender that Mo'unga. For me, his shit kicking from hand and 4 turnovers were a problem, although one of those was a knock on that would have been a try if he regathered.
I also see that they've updated the tackle stats - Paps had 23 made, zero missed.
like numbers for a guy who also got around the field so well. Given his size, we might be able to get away with Savea at 8 in a Rodders role if Paps can be the tackle machine and ball runner that Richie became during that time.That also means we need a Jerry Collins equivalent in the 6 - buggered if i know who that might be
@junior said in All Blacks 2022:
@gt12 said in All Blacks 2022:
Looking over the stats from last night, it's interesting reading, Mo'unga apparently only missed one tackle (made 3, missed 1), but it was a try conceding tackle and would be on that would interest international coaches (as @Crucial mentioned above).
Havili had a pretty good game on one side of the ball with a beautiful pass for a try assist, 7 runs, 3 defenders beaten, and 1 offload,. However, he missed 4 tackles (made 5) and I would say that international coaches will be examining those. I remember one was being stepped by Barrett but I think a couple of the others were related to the big runners coming down his channel (hope someone does a rewatch).
I think the point made above about defending in the line is a reasonable one for discussion, Barrett missed 3 tackles last night and made 2, but many here would argue that he is still a more effective defender that Mo'unga. For me, his shit kicking from hand and 4 turnovers were a problem, although one of those was a knock on that would have been a try if he regathered.
I also see that they've updated the tackle stats - Paps had 23 made, zero missed.
like numbers for a guy who also got around the field so well. Given his size, we might be able to get away with Savea at 8 in a Rodders role if Paps can be the tackle machine and ball runner that Richie became during that time.That also means we need a Jerry Collins equivalent in the 6 - buggered if i know who that might be
PGS or Vaai might be worth a shot? Or Barrett
-
@number9 The Fern is too much of a hostile environment to them to be arrogant on here. But maybe you mean in the real world. That could be entirely true.
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@number9 The Fern is too much of a hostile environment to them to be arrogant on here. But maybe you mean in the real world. That could be entirely true.
You know, just because you are earnest and serious doesn't mean you are right.
And despite what you say, you are as, if not more biased, than anyone.
And that's cool. It's what makes the Fern fun. Own it. Revel in it. Pick D Havili at 12 in a world XV. Pick Blackadder at 6. Have Jonah Lowe at 14. It's fun, that's what the Fern should be.
-
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@number9 The Fern is too much of a hostile environment to them to be arrogant on here. But maybe you mean in the real world. That could be entirely true.
You know, just because you are earnest and serious doesn't mean you are right.
And despite what you say, you are as, if not more biased, than anyone.
And that's cool. It's what makes the Fern fun. Own it. Revel in it. Pick D Havili at 12 in a world XV. Pick Blackadder at 6. Have Jonah Lowe at 14. It's fun, that's what the Fern should be.
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2022:
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@number9 The Fern is too much of a hostile environment to them to be arrogant on here. But maybe you mean in the real world. That could be entirely true.
You know, just because you are earnest and serious doesn't mean you are right.
And despite what you say, you are as, if not more biased, than anyone.
And that's cool. It's what makes the Fern fun. Own it. Revel in it. Pick D Havili at 12 in a world XV. Pick Blackadder at 6. Have Jonah Lowe at 14. It's fun, that's what the Fern should be.
I don't think I'm that biased. I just have different opinon. And suggesting those players for a World XV would be really silly. Why would I?
-
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2022:
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@number9 The Fern is too much of a hostile environment to them to be arrogant on here. But maybe you mean in the real world. That could be entirely true.
You know, just because you are earnest and serious doesn't mean you are right.
And despite what you say, you are as, if not more biased, than anyone.
And that's cool. It's what makes the Fern fun. Own it. Revel in it. Pick D Havili at 12 in a world XV. Pick Blackadder at 6. Have Jonah Lowe at 14. It's fun, that's what the Fern should be.
I don't think I'm that biased. I just have different opinon. And suggesting those players for a World XV would be really silly. Why would I?
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@mariner4life said in All Blacks 2022:
@stargazer said in All Blacks 2022:
@number9 The Fern is too much of a hostile environment to them to be arrogant on here. But maybe you mean in the real world. That could be entirely true.
You know, just because you are earnest and serious doesn't mean you are right.
And despite what you say, you are as, if not more biased, than anyone.
And that's cool. It's what makes the Fern fun. Own it. Revel in it. Pick D Havili at 12 in a world XV. Pick Blackadder at 6. Have Jonah Lowe at 14. It's fun, that's what the Fern should be.
I don't think I'm that biased. I just have different opinon. And suggesting those players for a World XV would be really silly. Why would I?
Lol.embrace it bro, it makes it fun
You are and that's totally cool. We all have our mancrushes
-
- Aaron
- Beaudy
- Clarke
- Jordie
- Rieko
- Reece
- Jordan
That's a starting backline I want to see. Power, size, speed and elusiveness. Reece is easily the best right wing in New Zealand. Jordan is too good not to start at fullback where he can get more opportunities. Clarke is the form left winger. Rieko is the form centre and has pace to burn. Aaron's pass can ensure Beaudy can run into space and if he needs to bail out, Jordie has the size and skillset to get over the advantage line.
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2022:
- Aaron
- Beaudy
- Clarke
- Jordie
- Rieko
- Reece
- Jordan
That's a starting backline I want to see. Power, size, speed and elusiveness. Reece is easily the best right wing in New Zealand. Jordan is too good not to start at fullback where he can get more opportunities. Clarke is the form left winger. Rieko is the form centre and has pace to burn. Aaron's pass can ensure Beaudy can run into space and if he needs to bail out, Jordie has the size and skillset to get over the advantage line.
Looking bloody good if all 7 players are fit and in form. My only question mark is Reece's defence. Someone really needs to teach him proper tackling technique and not so with the arms.
-
While I don't necessarily disagree with this, but according to the Fern a first 15 AB team would arguably only have Whitelock, Jordan and possibly Reece from the Crusaders. Yet, they have been the bench mark as a team for the last few years and last night the Blues scraped home. Somebody must be doing something right. Coaching? A team being better than the sum of its parts?
This post is deleted! -
- Aaron
- Beaudy
- Clarke
- Jordie
- Rieko
- Reece
- Jordan
That's a starting backline I want to see. Power, size, speed and elusiveness. Reece is easily the best right wing in New Zealand. Jordan is too good not to start at fullback where he can get more opportunities. Clarke is the form left winger. Rieko is the form centre and has pace to burn. Aaron's pass can ensure Beaudy can run into space and if he needs to bail out, Jordie has the size and skillset to get over the advantage line.
@antipodean said in All Blacks 2022:
- Aaron
- Beaudy
- Clarke
- Jordie
- Rieko
- Reece
- Jordan
That's a starting backline I want to see. Power, size, speed and elusiveness. Reece is easily the best right wing in New Zealand. Jordan is too good not to start at fullback where he can get more opportunities. Clarke is the form left winger. Rieko is the form centre and has pace to burn. Aaron's pass can ensure Beaudy can run into space and if he needs to bail out, Jordie has the size and skillset to get over the advantage line.
- Christie
- Porefeta (10/15)
- Someone who can cover midfield (Jordan & Ioane already cover wing, Jordie covers 15 too). Would have had ALB but injured.
